Mind Matters Natural and Artificial Intelligence News and Analysis

CategoryLarge Language Models (LLMs)

ai-brain-chip-loop-artificial-intelligence-rationality-human-quantum-metrology-mind-circuit-board-neuronal-network-random-access-memory-smart-computer-processor-endorphins-stockpack-adobe-stock
AI Brain Chip loop. Artificial Intelligence rationality human quantum metrology mind circuit board. Neuronal network random access memory smart computer processor endorphins

Computer Intelligence Versus Human Intelligence

Professor Joseph Weizenbaum created a chatbot he named ELIZA that conversed with users the way a psychotherapist might

Even though the users knew they were interacting with a computer, many were convinced that the program had human-like intelligence and emotions and they happily shared their deepest feelings and most closely held secrets.

Read More ›
deepfake-parrot-stochastic-parrot-for-large-language-models-1226318002-stockpack-adobestock
deepfake parrot - stochastic parrot for large language models and artificial intelligence technology

Large Language Models (LLMs) Are Inherently Frail and Unreliable

From my recent tests, things have not improved much. Even an apparent improvement did not last long. See for yourself

Post-training might stabilize the responses to specific inquiries but then the bot can just go off the rails again, as my tests showed.

Read More ›
shovel-and-pick-axe-in-digital-background-a-concept-of-data-96436480-stockpack-adobestock
Shovel and pick axe in digital background / A concept of data mining

The Core Problem with Large Language Models

LLMs are inherently unreliable, which means that failures are not incidental, easily fixable glitches

The data deluge exponentially increases the number of coincidental, useless statistical patterns — so the probability of useful patterns approaches zero.

Read More ›
abstract-ai-humans-head-wireframe-with-digital-0-and-1-background-stockpack-adobe-stock.jpg
Abstract Ai human's head wireframe with digital 0 and 1 background

WHY DO CHATBOTS LEAD LEARNERS ASTRAY?

How interface‑level social cues encourage relational engagement with chatbots

Big Tech’s signature exploitative strategies optimize for engagement, not for truth. By manipulating our behavioural psychology in this way, chatbots become top of mind when we have a question about anything, or just need a friend.

Read More ›
trust-concept-stockpack-adobe-stock.jpg
Trust Concept

The serious limitations on what AI can do in education

Interrogating trust, power, and data governance in the era of neuro‑surveillance

Have we become so accustomed to surveillance capitalism that we are completely blinded to the implications? Or has Big Tech become so trustworthy that we can trust them to handle the data of student brain states with benevolent intent?

Read More ›
tree-monument-valley-usa-stockpack-adobe-stock-115835146-stockpack-adobestock
tree monument valley - usa

Is OpenAI Approaching the Valley of Death?

Overpromising is still a big problem; in any event, the fate of Netscape looms

OpenAI needs to show that ChatGPT is more than just the first publicly available LLM. It has not done that and maybe never will.

Read More ›
programmer-working-on-their-professional-development-types-on-a-laptop-computer-keyboard-coding-language-user-interface-on-screens-development-of-software-and-coding-chatgpt-ai-and-webdesign-stockpack-adobe-stock
Programmer working on their professional development types on a laptop computer keyboard. Coding Language User Interface on Screens. Development of software and coding, ChatGPT AI and webdesign

Why I Respectfully Disagree With Bill Dembski on AI in Education

Are GenAI chatbots really the bridge over the gulf of our education crisis?

Dr. Dembski wants us to use technology with wisdom. I share his broader goal, but not the use of generative AI chatbots to get there.

Read More ›
llm-ai-large-language-model-concept-businessman-use-tablet-a-886081817-stockpack-adobe_stock
LLM, AI Large Language Model concept. Businessman use tablet and laptop with LLM icons. A language model distinguished by its general-purpose language generation capability. Chat AI.

The Chatbots’ Most Dangerous Correlations

To give these machines blind trust really is the case of the blind leading the blind, and that is not likely to end well

When you prompt an LLM, the entire conversation acts as a prompt driving the reply. Thus your prompt can push the LLM in unforeseen, unintended directions.

Read More ›
ai-global-network-a-blue-vision-of-future-technology-stockpa-700652610-stockpack-adobestock
AI Global Network: A Blue Vision of Future Technology

The Generative AI Bubble Has Begun to Pop

From hype to hard realities in the age of artificial intelligence

Recently, talk of a bubble has increased as it has become clear that OpenAI, and likely other AI software companies, may never become profitable.

Read More ›
evil-ai-agent-robot-hacking-stockpack-adobe-stock-1330157571-stockpack-adobestock
Evil AI agent robot hacking

Does It Matter WHY a Chatbot Slanders You?

Google’s AI chatbot service blames users’ questions and unfixable software for the bot’s shocking defamation of a man’s character

Chatbots aren’t necessities. Meanwhile, long-esteemed laws and rules of conduct forbade slander and libel because they can seriously harm people.

Read More ›
city-skyline-shrouded-in-a-thick-layer-of-fog-elevated-aeria-1622244505-stockpack-adobestock
City skyline, shrouded in a thick layer of fog. Elevated aerial view reveals numerous high-rise buildings emerging from a dense cloud cover. A clear, pale blue sky is visible above the clouds

A Lack of Transparency Threatens AI — and the American Economy

Even the Wall Street Journal does not appear to understand the nature of the looming problems

AI software startups should be required to release audited numbers so that we can at least understand the current state of the AI economy.

Read More ›
a-child-holding-a-tablet-with-a-chatbot-interface-on-the-scr-1152739883-stockpack-adobestock
A child holding a tablet with a chatbot interface on the screen, showing colorful icons and a cheerful robot character.

Kids and Chatbots: How Dissenting Views Got Me Disinvited

As a lifelong software engineer, I am an insider on a topic like this and I know that their programming makes them unsuitable for children

I also believe that their programmed tendency to lead to addictive relationships makes them unsuitable for adults as well but that’s another topic.

Read More ›
the-skill-to-dissect-complex-data-recognize-patterns-and-mak-1563298424-stockpack-adobestock
The skill to dissect complex data, recognize patterns, and make logical decisions based on relationships and cause-effect.

Illusions: No, Large Language Models Do Not Understand

A recent New Yorker article is mistaken about this. For one thing, the LLMs have trouble distinguishing between causation and mere correlation

A real-world example of such struggles is the poor performance, in general, of AI-powered mutual funds.

Read More ›
courtroom-symbolizes-law-and-authority-through-a-judgment-ga-1533281955-stockpack-adobestock
Courtroom symbolizes law and authority through a judgment gavel

Case Study: How Not to Sue AI for Libel

I personally favor modernizing the civil laws against libel and defamation to take into account the type of injuries that chatbots can inflict.

Read More ›
a-futuristic-eco-city-with-verdant-vegetation-and-a-glowing-1471859222-stockpack-adobestock
A futuristic eco-city with verdant vegetation and a glowing green energy source situated atop a giant computer chip in a detailed urban landscape vision.

Should Christians Harness AI Chatbots As a Force For Good? Part 2

The claims being made for what these bots can do for ministry would lead us into dangerous territory

We need to remember what Christian thinkers like C.S. Lewis and Marshall McLuhan have thought and said about technology-driven utopias.

Read More ›
futuristic-scholar-teen-girl-in-school-ambience-generative-a-627837675-stockpack-adobestock
Futuristic Scholar teen Girl in School Ambience, generative ai

A Non-Transhumanist Vision for AI in Education

Bill Dembski describes this new approach as amounting to edification rather than enhancement

AI should be used as a way of honing students’ skills and knowledge, helping them learn more effectively than before.

Read More ›
woman-chained-to-a-laptop-symbolizing-internet-and-social-me-808387718-stockpack-adobestock
Woman chained to a laptop, symbolizing internet and social media addiction. Generated by AI

Should Christians Harness AI Chatbots As A Force For Good? Part 1

In response to claims from a Christian ministry, as a Christian software developer, I offer some serious cautions

A technology like generative AI, which deceives us by feeling person-like, harms us in ways that are categorically different from any other.

Read More ›
will-rogers-stockpack-adobe-stock-36846391-stockpack-adobestock
Will Rogers

Scaling Up is Not Going to Make Large Language Models Intelligent

ChatGPT-5 misunderstood the jab in a simple Will Rogers joke five out of six times

Bigger data centers are not going to change the harsh reality that LLMs are prone to generating unreliable blather.

Read More ›
chat-gpt-artificial-intelligence-copy-writing-bot-by-open-ai-611480062-stockpack-adobestock
Chat GPT Artificial Intelligence copy writing bot by Open AI. Robot for student homework, education.

Large Language Models: Inconsistent Because They’re Unintelligent

Here’s what happened when I tested popular LLMs on student exercise questions I have been using for over fifty years

Claims that an LLM is intelligent don’t square with the fact that it may answer a question one way and, a few seconds later, simply contradict itself.

Read More ›
aidriven-chatbots-assisting-customer-service-automated-commu-873108619-stockpack-adobestock
AIdriven chatbots assisting customer service, automated communication, concept

Will Reliance on AI Mean a Vast Drop in New Knowledge Production?

Dependence on AI assistants, for example, was found to greatly reduce discussion among peers, where new ideas are offered and evaluated

Ultimately, the AI knowledge system will be enriched or impoverished by human decisions, not by discovering a superintelligence.

Read More ›