Mind Matters Natural and Artificial Intelligence News and Analysis

CategoryPhilosophy of Mind

dented-car-wing-and-fender-with-scratches-and-bumps-after-cr-448422384-stockpack-adobestock
Dented car wing and fender with scratches and bumps after crash and car accident with hit-and-run driving and absconding shows need for car insurance and safety protection and mechanics garage service

On Free Will and Morality, Jerry Coyne Doesn’t Walk His Talk

This is part of my response to his critique of a talk I gave in March at the 2026 Dallas Conference on Science and Faith

Everyone believes in free will, including Coyne. He writes sophistry denying free will but he rails at the moral reprobate who dented his fender.

Read More ›
surgery-anesthesia-and-doctor-with-woman-with-oxygen-mask-fo-636901246-stockpack-adobestock
Surgery, anesthesia and doctor with woman with oxygen mask for medical service, operation and procedure. Healthcare, hospital and surgeons with gas, breathing and ventilation equipment for patient

Are We Really “Unconscious” While Under Anesthesia?

Modern medics rely very much on anesthesia but how it works is not quite clear

Part of the reason we don’t know exactly how anesthesia works is surely that we do not know what consciousness is (there are at least 325 theories out there).

Read More ›
body-mind-soul-spirit-motivational-words-quotes-concept-stoc-1110324376-stockpack-adobestock
Body Mind Soul Spirit, Motivational Words Quotes Concept

what makes a thought start?

When a doctor is taunted for his lack of knowledge of consciousness and the soul

Good dialogue is like great poetry where the real meaning can sometimes be hidden or disguised beneath the words.

Read More ›
mission-over-a-robot-stands-at-the-grave-of-man-stockpack-ad-349542895-stockpack-adobestock
mission over, a robot stands at the grave of man

Future? There Is No Human Future, Dude… and That’s Good!

A look at the other face of the claims that we are approaching an AI singularity

Lê’s essay offers a much more sober assessment of transhumanism, the war on human exceptionalism, and the idea that machines think like people.

Read More ›
womans-head-hidden-by-a-soft-cloud-stockpack-adobe-stock-150476232-stockpack-adobestock
Woman's head hidden by a soft cloud

Why Do Smart People Think Their Minds Are an Illusion?

A belief that makes no sense is a cornerstone of much neuroscience and philosophy of mind

Michael Egnor comments that academics often hold such beliefs because they make them sound clever, not because they make sense.

Read More ›
man-in-surreal-maze-facing-labyrinth-challenge-complex-probl-626634793-stockpack-adobestock
Man in surreal maze, facing labyrinth challenge, complex problem decision, strategy for success, concept of life obstacles and solutions

Can We Talk the Hard Problem of Consciousness Out of Existence?

A prominent theoretical physicist thinks it is worth a try

We don’t have a reason to expect the eliminative materialism Carlo Rovelli recommends, which has not helped in the past, to be more help in the future.

Read More ›
love-song-stockpack-adobe-stock-311614-stockpack-adobestock
love song

Why Memories Cannot Really Be “Stored” Anywhere

A song might capture the immaterial nature of memory

Where exactly is a popular song located? It lives in memory, human and recorded, in many forms. But it occupies no spatial location.

Read More ›
memories-stockpack-adobe-stock-18420385-stockpack-adobestock
Memories

Philosopher: Memories Are Not “Stored” in the Brain

Memory is a function of time, not place, says Oxford's Victoria Trumbull

Neurosurgeon Michael Egnor agrees; the image of storing and erasing memories is popular due to computer technology but not relevant to memory.

Read More ›
single-naked-flame-in-black-space-stockpack-adobe-stock-203509572-stockpack-adobestock
Single naked flame in black space.

What Do People Who Are Conscious But Lack a Cortex Demonstrate?

Consciousness does not necessarily reside in the cortex, as is commonly assumed

Neuroplasticity is a very interesting and important area of research. But the careless and casual attribution of unexpected mental states to it is junk science.

Read More ›
businessman-using-virtual-metaverse-and-future-digital-techn-717435569-stockpack-adobestock
Businessman using virtual metaverse and future digital technology , Virtual Global Internet connection network with AI Artificial Intelligence digital

The Pope Just Weighed In On AI

If your religious organization doesn’t yet have a theology of AI, start building one because the conversation is already happening without you

The question isn’t whether AI will harm us. The question is actually whether we will remain human.

Read More ›
portrait-dun-homo-erectus-assis-et-regardant-le-coucher-du-s-845655116-stockpack-adobestock
Portrait d'un Homo erectus assis et regardant le coucher du soleil

Ancient Humans Have Been Getting Smarter, It Seems

That’s the conclusion I drew from reading about recent research in paleontology

Technology has a history but the human mind does not. We see it where we see it.

Read More ›
a-photorealistic-view-of-an-abstract-puzzle-with-a-magnifyin-1417289590-stockpack-adobestock
A photorealistic view of an abstract puzzle with a magnifying glass highlighting a missing piece shaped like a question mark, symbolizing problem-solving and critical thinking.

Why Egnor Finds Neuroscientists’ Lack of Curiosity “Unbelievable”

It seems as if they simply do not want to know about findings that challenge materialism

Unfortunately, some of them spend a lot of time trying to discredit people who are willing to look at these questions.

Read More ›
family-of-ancient-neanderthal-people-in-cave-close-up-man-wo-662879066-stockpack-adobestock
Family of ancient Neanderthal people in cave close-up, man, woman and child with long matted hair dressed in animal skins

We need to catch up with the Neanderthals!

A number of interesting new findings and discussions have appeared — on everything from their dentistry to bear worship

Some of the Neanderthals’ practices around skulls suggest that they followed a belief system.

Read More ›
a-secret-garden-back-door-with-a-whimsical-outdoor-retreat-s-683731574-stockpack-adobestock
A secret garden back door with a whimsical outdoor retreat.

Do People With Split Brains Have Back Door Communications?

Some neuroscientists think that split brain communications can thus be explained that way. Michael Egnor disagrees

The simpler explanation, he says, is that percepts, perceptions travel through axons. Conceptions don’t travel through axons because they’re not material.

Read More ›
image-illustrates-striking-representation-of-human-mind-divi-1741196152-stockpack-adobestock
image illustrates striking representation of human mind, divided into two contrasting halves. One side features blue brain against pink background, while other s orange brain yellow

The Astonishing Fact That Split Brain Patients Reveal

Perception (what we take in from the world around us) can be split but conception (ideas) are not split. And no one has two minds

A misguided article in Popular Mechanics gave neurosurgeon Michael Egnor a chance to shed light on a unique fact about people with split brains here.

Read More ›
a-choice-of-two-ways-woman-at-a-crossroads-stockpack-adobe-stock
A choice of two ways. Woman at a crossroads.

Another ‘Scientific’ Attack on Free Will

We know free will exists because we each experience it every day.

Accepting that we are merely flesh marionettes dancing to the strings pulled by our various biological processes would doom human decency.

Read More ›
domestic-parrot-in-a-cage-looks-at-its-reflection-in-the-mir-774816161-stockpack-adobestock
Domestic parrot in a cage looks at its reflection in the mirror. Beautiful parrot, close-up, selective focus, pet. Parrot and mirror. Colored bird

What Is Consciousness Actually Supposed To Do?

The Royal Society offers sixteen theories of the evolutionary function of consciousness. The trouble is, it's not clear what consciousness even is

Some of the theories of animal mind are interesting but no one really has any idea how consciousness originated.

Read More ›
goal-to-success-for-level-up-with-person-climbing-on-route-slope-to-mountain-peakhuman-performance-limit-conceptsgrowth-mindset-and-motivationgenerative-ai-technology-stockpack-adobe-stock
Goal to success for level up with person climbing on route slope to mountain peak.human performance limit concepts.growth mindset and motivation.generative ai technology

Understanding the Atheist’s Mind

Naturalism is the belief that everything in the universe is a blind accident, with no ultimate purpose.

In a Godless universe, love, self-sacrifice, friendship, relationships, pro-creation, art and literature are nothing more than relatively subjective illusions to pass the time and avoid boredom with no ultimate purpose or objective meaning.

Read More ›
psychology-stockpack-adobe-stock-271944238-stockpack-adobestock
Psychology.

How Much Does the Mind Weigh? How Long Is It?

A recent article at Popular Mechanics provides a chance to reflect on mind vs. matter — and materialism

People are entitled to their own definitions of materialism, of course. But once we focus on a standard one, we see that it is false to the reality of the human mind.

Read More ›
person-uses-laptop-interacting-with-ai-virtual-assistant-ai-1133554305-stockpack-adobestock
Person uses laptop interacting with AI virtual assistant. AI head graphic overlay laptop keyboard. Concept of AI prompt engineering, LLM. Person types on keyboard to communicate with virtual

Who Expected Richard Dawkins To Blow Up Darwinism?

To the astonishment and dismay of a computer pro who once admired him, Dawkins, who has a materialist view of human consciousness, has convinced himself that a chatbot is conscious

If this is what happens when people think that human consciousness has a purely material evolutionary origin, it is a strong argument for the opposite view.

Read More ›