Mind Matters Natural and Artificial Intelligence News and Analysis

CategoryPhilosophy of Mind

a-large-symphony-orchestra-performs-in-a-majestic-concert-ha-758496004-stockpack-adobestock
A large symphony orchestra performs in a majestic concert hall, led by a conductor, under grand chandeliers

Missing Brains and the “Music Model” of Consciousness

Gazzaniga and Queenan’s new model accounts for missing brain parts but it leaves out the very thing that creates the music
Even so, Michael Egnor sees it as a “radical shift in the discussion about neuroscience and consciousness, at the highest levels of the neuroscience community.” Read More ›
a-cluster-of-tiny-tea-candles-gently-floating-on-a-dark-rive-1246319212-stockpack-adobestock
A cluster of tiny tea candles gently floating on a dark river illuminating the water with soft golden light

Taking the Side of Science — But How Do We Know Which One It Is?

In writing that science’s materialism is absolute, Richard Lewontin wrote as one who did not grasp the fatal flaw in his absolutism
If the mind is an illusion of the brain, the pursuit of science is illusory too. If the mind is real but immaterial, science is saved — but materialism is dead. Read More ›
urban-pigeons-a-sunlit-gathering-in-city-steps-stockpack-ado-1233844725-stockpack-adobestock
Urban Pigeons: A Sunlit Gathering in City Steps

Part 2: Have the Superbirds Arrived? Are They Taking Over?

Dr. Avian now claims that his work with trained birds show that intelligence does not require inner models or internal representations, as formerly thought
Avian is perfectly clear: There is no mind at all in Coordinated Avian Models (CAMs). And yet, they’re behind a staggering number of new designs. Read More ›
split gold head
Abstract concept illustration from 3D rendering of a golden female head sculpture cut divided showing black interior halves and isolated on grey background.

Conundrum: Split Human Brain But Unified Perception

1500 papers later, current research suggests that a non-materialist approach to the neuroscience of the human mind is quite viable
Researcher Yair Pinto summed it up: In split-brain, patients, perception is split, but consciousness is unified. Read More ›
head-of-a-woman-showing-different-states-of-mind-and-being-through-tranparency-stockpack-adobe-stock
Head of a woman - showing different states of mind and being through tranparency

Science: Slowly Accepting a Non-Materialist View of the Mind?

Ken Francis’s comments at New English Review brought back memories
If the evidence suggests that aspects of the human mind are immaterial, what does it mean to say that “science” says it can’t be true? Read More ›
ability-stockpack-adobe-stock-406704449-stockpack-adobestock
Ability.

Does the Mind Have a Specific Location in the Brain?

A rabbi asks neurosurgeon Michael Egnor how consciousness can exist without a place in the brain
The conventional assumption today is that consciousness has a material source. Yet no one has found a place where it lives in the brain. Read More ›
physics-or-mathematical-equations-on-a-universe-decorative-l-623641232-stockpack-adobestock
Physics or mathematical equations on a universe decorative LED background give the impression of interstellar space travel.

How Studying AI Helped a Prof See Why the Mind is Non-Physical

A computer science professor shows, using logic, how you must be more than mere matter
Chatbots process enormous amounts of data and produce convincing outputs but, he says, they do not grasp the meaning of the concepts they manipulate. Read More ›
Two Scientists in the Brain Research Laboratory work on a Project, Using Personal Computer with MRI Scans Show Brain Anomalies. Neuroscientists at Work.
Two Scientists in the Brain Research Laboratory work on a Project, Using Personal Computer with MRI Scans Show Brain Anomalies. Neuroscientists at Work.

Can Faith and Neuroscience Align? Yes, Says Science Writer

If both faith and neuroscience are honestly seeking the truth, says Denyse O’Leary, they will find much that is mutually supportive
That is the key message behind the new book, The Immortal Mind (2025), of which she is neurosurgeon Michael Egnor’s co-author. Read More ›
brain-psychology-mind-soul-and-hope-concept-art-3d-illustrat-477180129-stockpack-adobe_stock
Brain psychology mind soul and hope concept art, 3d illustration, surreal artwork, imagination painting, conceptual idea

Podcast: Neurosurgeon Michael Egnor Reads From The Immortal Mind

He followed the evidence and came to see that the human mind has a spiritual and immortal dimension
About existential questions, he says, "I no longer settled for the stock answers that many scientists, like me, had naively accepted for so long." Read More ›
light-in-dark-cave-with-stalactites-3d-illustration-stockpac-361367105-stockpack-adobestock
light in dark cave with stalactites 3d illustration

Ancient Burials Are in the News Again — for Good Reason

Archaeologists are reporting on a group culture around death from 100,000 years ago, maybe involving both Neanderthals and modern humans
The controversy around possible homo Naledi burials (335,000 to 245,000 years ago) has also broken out again. Read More ›
operating-doctor-in-hospital-neurosurgery-specilaists-workin-588448824-stockpack-adobestock
Operating doctor in hospital. Neurosurgery specilaists working in emergency room.

A Podcast Host Asks, How Many Neurosurgeons Are Materialists…?

Will Spencer asked neurosurgeon Michael Egnor how he responds to colleagues who believe that we are just meat puppets
In Egnor’s view, materialism does not seem nearly as prevalent among neurosurgeons as among neuroscientists, who face more grant-driven pressure to conform. Read More ›
brain-head-human-mental-idea-mind-3d-illustration-background-322087988-stockpack-adobestock
Brain head human mental idea mind 3D illustration background

Iain McGilchrist on Consciousness, Materialism, and Religion

Don't forget the right side of the brain
"The left hemisphere, left to itself, is deluded," says McGilchrist. It lacks context. It will try to force things into its own purview. Read More ›
brain-mind-way-soul-and-hope-concept-art-illustration-surrea-425584966-stockpack-adobe_stock
Brain mind way soul and hope concept art, illustration, surreal mystery artwork, imagination painting, conceptual idea of success

An Ancient Argument for the Existence of the Human Soul

Sixteen hundred years ago, Augustine tells a friend about a dream a skeptical local doctor had, where a sharp youth asked him some pointed questions
One issue that arose in that age of controversy was how anything like a human mind could function without a body? Read More ›
mind-stockpack-adobe-stock-407320224-stockpack-adobestock
Mind.

Consciousness and Free Will: JP Moreland’s Case for Dualism

He argues that dualism, the sense that we are souls as well as bodies, is the natural interpretation of our lived experience
Moreland contends thatthe dualist view isn’t an irrational leap of faith but a well-supported, philosophically robust position. Read More ›
wooden-bubble-speech-and-signs-yes-and-no-stockpack-adobe-st-643715319-stockpack-adobestock
Wooden Bubble speech and signs yes and no.

Science Dilemma: Bucking the Trend and Searching for Truth

Neurosurgeon Michael Egnor tells host Allan CP about the risks scientists face if they say that human beings have souls
The discussion touched on many areas covered by the new book, The Immortal Mind, but one scientist’s dilemma stood out. Read More ›
Phanerochaetevelutina2-lindsey

Do Fungi Demonstrate a Form of Intelligence? What Does That Mean?

Yes, the natural world is full of intelligence and we are only scratching the surface of it. But…
Human intelligence is different. For one thing, we think about what we are thinking about — the ultimate abstract process because both elements are immaterial. Read More ›
landscape-and-sky-at-sunset-stockpack-adobe-stock-145863988-stockpack-adobestock
Landscape and Sky at Sunset

Does Dementia Show That the Mind Is Simply What the Brain Does?

People with dementia have severe memory issues, along with motor, perception and emotional disabilities, and that curtails their powers of reason
But, while the mind generally depends on a healthy brain, sometimes lucidity can come surging back to a demented person briefly and unexpectedly. Read More ›
doctor-reviews-brain-scans-stockpack-adobe-stock-1284682992-stockpack-adobestock
Doctor reviews brain scans

Burying Stories Is No Way to Advance Science

A story about a man with a severe brain defect who led an apparently normal life has been almost buried in efforts to explain it away
Michael Egnor and I wrote The Immortal Mind to show that the mind is not simply what the brain does and this story is but one example among many. Read More ›
two-brains-connected-by-a-bridge-over-darkness-in-an-artisti-1201883404-stockpack-adobestock
Two Brains Connected By A Bridge Over Darkness In An Artistic Graphic Illustration

Neuroscientist Christof Koch proposes a bold brain experiment…

… worthy of science fiction — that he and his debate opponent, neurosurgeon Michael Egnor, could share a brain via Neuralink. And what would happen then?
Koch hoped that the “shared brain” experiment would demonstrate materialism. He may have been unprepared for Egnor’s response. Read More ›
digital-illustration-of-a-brain-split-into-blue-and-red-hemi-1557593822-stockpack-adobestock
Digital illustration of a brain split into blue and red hemispheres with a glowing connection.

Neuroscientist: Brain Surgery Can Create “Two Conscious Entities”

Dr. Egnor, who has done split-brain surgery himself, dismisses neuroscientist Christof Koch's claim
Egnor: Consciousness is not the kind of thing that can be split, and there’s no evidence that one person can ever become two people. Read More ›