Mind Matters Natural and Artificial Intelligence News and Analysis

CategoryPhilosophy of Mind

empty-classic-red-chinese-room-stockpack-adobe-stock-753536499-stockpack-adobestock
empty classic red chinese room

Philosopher of Mind and Language John Searle Has Died

His Chinese Room thought experiment, an argument for why computers can seem clever without having minds, was widely understood among the lay public

The Chinese Room thought experiment helped us see the nature of computation, as opposed to human thinking.

Read More ›
fogbow-over-misty-green-hills-at-sunrise-rainbow-dawn-stockp-1617621356-stockpack-adobestock
Fogbow over misty green hills at sunrise rainbow dawn

Why the Soul Doesn’t — and Can’t — Weigh Anything

The question has nothing to do with whether or not the soul exists

Dr. Duncan MacDougall’s attempts to weigh the soul were ingenious as well as controversial but he misunderstood the soul’s nature.

Read More ›
a-humanoid-robot-philosopher-contemplating-the-nature-of-con-1228267447-stockpack-adobestock
A humanoid robot philosopher contemplating the nature of consciousness in a virtual reality chamber, abstract digital environment with neural networks and philosophical texts, Innovative style

Brain Surgeon Shows Why AI Can Never Become Human

Spoiler alert: AI requires physical hardware; the mind does not

AI can never be more than a machine; the human mind soars far above any machine model. Be nice to your robot. But don’t think she is human.

Read More ›
cognitive-researcher-conducting-perception-experiment-with-v-1664019810-stockpack-adobestock
Cognitive Researcher Conducting Perception Experiment with Visual Stimuli Under Natural Light, Selective Focus and Flat Lay Setup

Materialism in Science: Touching Another Hot Button

With a discussion of the findings of rigorous research into telepathy, the challenge to the presumption of materialism in science is beginning to be sounded loud and clear

What’s changed? The cost of protecting materialism in science has risen gradually, consistent with the rising number of situations on which it sheds little light.

Read More ›
dynamic-energy-fields-illustration-depicting-electromagnetic-1425086109-stockpack-adobestock
Dynamic energy fields illustration depicting electromagnetic waves, representing theoretical physics concepts like Maxwell's equations with intricate detail and vibrant colors

What If Science Tried Doing Without Materialism?

In a thoughtful review of The Immortal Mind, John Zmirak points to the way it currently underlies most popular presentations of science

Without materialism. math still adds up, physics and chemistry are still true, and logic still works. Only forgettable projects would be forgotten.

Read More ›
humanity-upload-concept-of-digital-consciousness-and-technol-1618978255-stockpack-adobestock
Humanity Upload – Concept of Digital Consciousness and Technological Evolution

Consciousness Can’t Be Uploaded as AI? — Of Course It Can’t!

Converting ideas and memories into bits in a computer program does not recreate in the computer the person whose minds and memories they are — only a simulation

The uploaded quirks and memories may be a good simulation of the deceased person but it is not a surviving self. It is just data.

Read More ›
black-and-white-shot-of-an-asphalt-road-with-a-selective-foc-430682810-stockpack-adobestock
Black and white shot of an asphalt road with a selective focus on a white contrast arrow on it as a road marking leading to a concrete wall and a turn to the left, sunny day, shallow depth of field

Michael Egnor at The Stream: How Materialists Refute Themselves

In Part 3, he also talks about how fellow health care personnel and patients have responded to The Immortal Mind, which makes a case for the immortal soul

People I work with in the operating room and clinics and even patients tell me that they read our book and really liked it. They are glad we are speaking up.

Read More ›
brain-mind-way-soul-and-hope-concept-art-illustration-surrea-425584966-stockpack-adobe_stock
Brain mind way soul and hope concept art, illustration, surreal mystery artwork, imagination painting, conceptual idea of success

Michael Egnor at The Stream: How the Mind Transcends the Brain

In his interview with John Zmirak, Dr. Egnor points out that epileptic seizures do not involve abstract thought because that type of thought is not simply a product of the brain

He noted that pioneer neurosurgeon Wilder Penfield started out as a materialist but became a dualist as a result of discovering things like these.

Read More ›
three-piglets-little-pink-pigs-with-raised-ears-looking-at-s-277789395-stockpack-adobestock
Three piglets little pink pigs with raised ears looking at same direction and standing on hay in a farm

Why the Mind Matters: No Free Will = No Guilt — Thus No Innocence

Michael Egnor spells out the true consequences of materialism: We come to be seen as animals to be managed by government

Materialism, Egnor says, is rarely defended explicitly; rather, objections are brushed off and prominent objectors may be Canceled.

Read More ›
a-robot-doing-yoga-contemplating-its-existence-ai-and-techno-1181750288-stockpack-adobestock
A robot doing yoga, contemplating its existence, ai and technology concept

AI Consciousness Myths: Neuroscientist Offers a No-Hype Approach

Àlex Gómez-Marín’s physics background shows in the way that he dissects the hyped-up claims before responding to them

At present, it doesn’t sound as though consciousness studies can take us beyond our natural folk understanding of consciousness.

Read More ›
group-of-happy-diverse-senior-people-standing-together-stock-630088052-stockpack-adobestock
Group of happy diverse senior people standing together.

Researchers: Sense of Purpose in Later Life Lowers Dementia Risk

They believe that it helps the brain stay resilient. Fortunately, a wide range of activities have been found in various studies to provide that sense

While the observed effect was small, any actual effect is a tool in the box and this one does not come with the risks associated with medications.

Read More ›
brain-psychology-mind-soul-and-hope-concept-art-3d-illustration-surreal-artwork-imagination-painting-conceptual-idea-stockpack-adobe-stock
Brain psychology mind soul and hope concept art, 3d illustration, surreal artwork, imagination painting, conceptual idea

Why Don’t Near-Death Experiences Support One Belief System?

On the Truthful Hope podcast, Jacob Vazquez and Denyse O'Leary discuss the way people of different faiths see what they themselves recognize

The mind that is having a near-death experience is separated from the body, relying on its own concepts. It is not necessarily a channel of divine truth.

Read More ›
exploring-the-intricate-connections-of-the-human-mind-throug-1220292688-stockpack-adobestock
Exploring the Intricate Connections of the Human Mind Through Gears and Creativity. Generative AI

Isn’t It a Bit Late To Try Retreading Eliminative Materialism?

Daniel Dennett was an eliminative materialist at a time when the idea that consciousness is an illusion sounded cool and daring. And the Big Explanation was just around the corner…

Overall, Jonny Thomson’s effort to keep Dennett’s eliminative materialism alive unintentionally points up how fragile it has actually become.

Read More ›
team-of-archaeologists-excavating-fossils-stockpack-adobe-st-458117077-stockpack-adobestock
Team of archaeologists excavating fossils

New Find: Stone Tools From 1 to 1.5 Million Years Ago

The tools were found on Sulawesi, an island near Flores, where fossils of diminutive humans were found in 2003 — but they were not as old as these tools

Human technology definitely has a history but the human mind does not. We see it where we see it, often just a glimpse in these abysses of time.

Read More ›
a-car-parked-on-the-side-of-the-road-an-empty-red-canister-t-518197569-stockpack-adobestock
A car parked on the side of the road, an empty red canister. The driver is on the road. Help on the road. Fuel shortage - oil, diesel, gasoline.

Is the Materialist Juggernaut Running Out of Fuel?

A recent thinkmag essay prompts a thought: can intellectuals still take materialism seriously?

Life would be so much easier for thinkmags if the mind were simply what the brain does. But wait. No one would produce thinkmags either.

Read More ›
wren-bird-closeup-stockpack-adobe-stock-651033338-stockpack-adobestock
Wren Bird Closeup

Part 3: A Wren Arrives — and Ruffles Many a Feather

Dr. Wren, a cognitive scientist, identifies a problem with assuming that adding another ten thousand pigeons to the project will produce novel designs...

We remain confronted by the same old mystery: who, or what, imagines the birdhouse in the first place?

Read More ›
silhouette-of-human-with-universe-and-physical-mathematical-287351146-stockpack-adobestock
Silhouette of human with universe and physical, mathematical formulas

At The Federalist: Science Is “Catching Up” to Philosophy

David Weinberg points out that traditional descriptions of the powers of our souls are remarkably like what modern neuroscience is revealing to us in the twenty-first century

The theme that science is confirming the traditional philosophical understanding of life is also the theme of David Klinghoffer’s Plato’s Revenge.

Read More ›
a-large-symphony-orchestra-performs-in-a-majestic-concert-ha-758496004-stockpack-adobestock
A large symphony orchestra performs in a majestic concert hall, led by a conductor, under grand chandeliers

Missing Brains and the “Music Model” of Consciousness

Gazzaniga and Queenan’s new model accounts for missing brain parts but it leaves out the very thing that creates the music

Even so, Michael Egnor sees it as a “radical shift in the discussion about neuroscience and consciousness, at the highest levels of the neuroscience community.”

Read More ›
a-cluster-of-tiny-tea-candles-gently-floating-on-a-dark-rive-1246319212-stockpack-adobestock
A cluster of tiny tea candles gently floating on a dark river illuminating the water with soft golden light

Taking the Side of Science — But How Do We Know Which One It Is?

In writing that science’s materialism is absolute, Richard Lewontin wrote as one who did not grasp the fatal flaw in his absolutism

If the mind is an illusion of the brain, the pursuit of science is illusory too. If the mind is real but immaterial, science is saved — but materialism is dead.

Read More ›
urban-pigeons-a-sunlit-gathering-in-city-steps-stockpack-ado-1233844725-stockpack-adobestock
Urban Pigeons: A Sunlit Gathering in City Steps

Part 2: Have the Superbirds Arrived? Are They Taking Over?

Dr. Avian now claims that his work with trained birds show that intelligence does not require inner models or internal representations, as formerly thought

Avian is perfectly clear: There is no mind at all in Coordinated Avian Models (CAMs). And yet, they’re behind a staggering number of new designs.

Read More ›