Mind Matters Natural and Artificial Intelligence News and Analysis

CategoryPhilosophy of Mind

open-eye-in-space-stockpack-adobe-stock
open eye in space

If Science Were Just Bookkeeping, Fine-Tuning Wouldn’t Matter

Astrophysicist Marcelo Gleiser wishes we would just quit asking questions about why the universe is fine-tuned — as if we could…
Calling assertions about fine-tuning — whether from theists or panpsychists — “astrotheology” will not help resolve any issues. Read More ›
generative-ai-black-men-twins-brothers-posing-outdoors-city-street-stockpack-adobe-stock
Generative ai black men twins brothers posing outdoors city street

The Explicitly Human Experience of Growing Up as a Twin

A philosopher muses on growing up as one of a set of two people
Understanding oneself as one of a set of twins is an abstract proposition. Considering what that entails, it’s a wonder that anyone doubts human exceptionalism. Read More ›
unstable-atom-nucleus-with-electrons-spinning-around-it-technology-background-stockpack-adobe-stock
Unstable Atom nucleus with electrons spinning around it technology background

Reflections on “Are Atoms Conscious?” and Philip Goff

Can we admit consciousness without giving into theism?
Goff claims the principle of parsimony is on his side, but what he gives us is minuscule in comparison to theism. Read More ›
heart-shaped-pill-between-rows-of-standard-pills-stockpack-adobe-stock
Heart shaped pill between rows of standard pills

Everyday Evidence of the Mind’s Reality: the Placebo Effect

The placebo effect — you get better because you think you will — may be getting stronger, as researchers manipulate it more effectively
Remember, if the mind is merely what the brain does and has no independent power, the placebo effect should not exist at all. And yet … Read More ›
Independent Thinking

The Free Will Debate Really Heated Up This Year

Many commentators are weighing in; surprisingly, perhaps, well-known materialists are disputing the claim that there is no free will
Given that both Pinker and Horgan are Darwinian materialists, their coldness toward the idea that there is no free will is worth keeping an eye on. Read More ›
human-brain-stimulation-or-activity-with-neuron-close-up-3d-rendering-illustration-neurology-cognition-neuronal-network-psychology-neuroscience-scientific-concepts-stockpack-adobe-stock
Human brain stimulation or activity with neuron close-up 3D rendering illustration. Neurology, cognition, neuronal network, psychology, neuroscience scientific concepts.

Will Neuroscience Ever Accommodate Immaterial Consciousness?

Joseph Green offers an informative account in Minding the Brain of the current state of neuroscience. What we now know is remarkable — but so is what we don’t
Just what will neuroscientists do if — even in their own minds — they do not succeed in showing that the mind is merely what the brain does? Read More ›
blue-moon-super-full-moon-august-moon-bright-stars-the-background-full-of-stars-in-the-galaxy-stockpack-adobe-stock
Blue Moon. Super Full moon august. Moon bright. Stars. The background full of stars in the galaxy.

Only an Immaterial Mind Can Ask “How Does Life Work?”

Science writer Philip Ball, facing cancer surgery, struggles to find meaning and purpose in a wholly material world. He is looking in the wrong place
Materialists want to banish meaning and purpose from science because they know perfectly well that only an immaterial mind could recognize meaning in anything. Read More ›
photo-taken-of-a-heartbeat-on-the-monitor-stockpack-adobe-stock
Photo taken of a heartbeat on the monitor

Yes, the Film on Near-Death Experiences Is Another “Hated Hit”

As with Sound of Freedom, critics trashed After Death but audiences loved it. And the critics just aren’t keeping up with the science
When even science mags are not trashing near-death researchers, critics who just assume it’s all bunk should really just get out more. Read More ›
beach-sandals-sepia-tone-stockpack-adobe-stock
beach sandals/ sepia tone

Footwear From Over 75,000 Years Ago? Some Fascinating Hints

Some researchers focus on changes in human foot bones, others on evidence of foot protection on ancient trackways
The insight, even back then, was envisioning what needs to be done. That part of the human mind has no history. Finding a way to do it follows. Read More ›
One of the stages of excavation

When Did Humans First Start Burying the Dead?

One of the things paleontologists look for is special care taken in the placement of the deceased's body
How could the insight that the human mind is not material and cannot really die the way the body dies get started? Did it always exist? Read More ›
Brain under water 3D render, subconscious mental life and brainstorm idea.

Why are eccentric theories of consciousness tolerated?

Even prominent theorists have held eccentric theories of consciousness. It stems from the apparent impossibility of deriving human consciousness from the material substances of the brain
If the scientific study of consciousness ever becomes more ideologically rigid — like evolutionary biology — it will also be less honest and less interesting. Read More ›
charting-consciousness-stockpack-adobe-stock.jpg
Charting Consciousness.

Can Roger Penrose Explain Consciousness Through Physics?

The Nobel Laureate physicist makes clear that he only wants a theory of human consciousness if the explanation comes down to physics
Perhaps the reason no theory of consciousness works is simply that the mind does not arise from molecules so theories of how that happens can’t work. Read More ›
synaps-with-neurons-in-the-background-neurotransmitters-in-synaptic-junction-information-transmission-in-the-brain-stockpack-adobe-stock
Synaps with neurons in the background, neurotransmitters in synaptic junction, information transmission in the brain

Neuroscience Has Never Provided Much Evidence for Materialism

In a chapter of the new book, Minding the Brain, neurosurgeon Michael Egnor points out that many great neuroscientists were non-materialists
Great neuroscientists weren’t dualists in spite of the evidence but because of it. Their research really did not support a materialist view of the mind. Read More ›
conceptual-image-of-brain-working-brain-in-thought-process-with-men-working-concept-of-mind-generating-ideas-trapped-brain-brain-taken-prisoner-generative-ai-stockpack-adobe-stock
Conceptual image of brain working. Brain in thought process with men working. Concept of mind generating ideas. Trapped brain. Brain taken prisoner. Generative ai.

How Could Human Consciousness “Evolve”?

Human consciousness entails a unique human ability to think abstractly .
According to Darwinian “science,” things changed, survivors survived, and the human ability to think abstractly materialized out of thin air. Read More ›
Choosing the High Road or Low Road

Modern Neuroscience Does NOT Disprove Free Will

In a chapter of Minding the Brain (2023), Cristi L. S. Cooper looks at the current state of neuroscience research on free will
In a chapter of Minding the Brain (2023), Cristi L. S. Cooper looks at the current state of neuroscience research on free will Read More ›
fishy-reflection-stockpack-adobe-stock
fishy reflection

The Mirror Test: The Key to a Sense of Self?

When fish and ants pass the test for “a higher sense of self” — but dogs and even kids in some cultures don’t — we should ask some questions
When fish and ants pass the test for “a higher sense of self” — but dogs and even kids in some cultures don’t — we should ask some questions Read More ›
child-in-womb-unborn-little-baby-in-utero-of-mother-development-of-human-fetus-during-pregnancy-family-planning-pregnancy-planning-concept-endure-pregnancy-and-easy-childbirth-generative-ai-stockpack-adobe-stock
Child in womb, unborn little baby in utero of mother, development of human fetus during pregnancy, family planning pregnancy planning concept, endure pregnancy and easy childbirth, generative AI

Researchers: Conscious Experience May Occur Near Time of Birth

Researchers generally stress that the unborn child’s brain is in a rapid, ongoing, and little understood state of development
We can’t know for sure but increasingly, the evidence favors assuming that some sort of mental development is possible. Read More ›
closeup-portrait-of-cute-baby-chimpanzee-dressed-in-blue-wool-jacket-generative-ai-stockpack-adobe-stock
Closeup portrait of cute baby chimpanzee dressed in blue wool jacket. Generative AI.

Psychology: When a Child and a Chimp Were Raised Together…

When their son was ten months old, a psychologist couple decided to raise him alongside a baby female chimpanzee, for research purposes
It ended sadly. No one has ever been able to give chimpanzees human minds — the real goal all along, surely — because the human mind is not a material thing. Read More ›
elephant-in-the-room-concept-of-a-controversial-issue-generative-ai-stockpack-adobe-stock
Elephant in the room, concept of a controversial issue, Generative AI

Science of Consciousness: The Elephant in the Room

Science has had great success in explaining many functions of living organisms in purely material terms. So why not consciousness?
After repeated failures to explain consciousness, there’s a new path in the science of consciousness that promises to be the final theory of consciousness. Read More ›
neural-pathways-in-a-brain-forming-intricate-patterns-metaphorically-showing-the-connections-within-the-human-mind-and-how-ideas-link-and-spark-stockpack-adobe-stock
Neural pathways in a brain forming intricate patterns, metaphorically showing the connections within the human mind and how ideas link and spark

The Human Mind Has No History

There is no good reason to assume that human intelligence evolved from mud to mind via a long slow history
When we look at the human past, we see lights flashing on suddenly. Technology evolves but not the mind as such. Read More ›