Mind Matters Natural and Artificial Intelligence News and Analysis

CategoryHuman exceptionalism

facial-recognition-technology-to-monitor-the-population-on-b-608983195-stockpack-adobestock
Facial recognition technology to monitor the population on busy street. Generative AI

The Real Threat AI Poses to Us Is Created by Widespread Abuse

In If Anyone Builds It, Yudkowsky and Soares are not really grappling with this problem
The authors really believe in AI doom. Soares has stopped contributing to a retirement plan. I show that the serious problem is NOT superintelligence. Read More ›
lush-green-cloud-forest-vegetation-with-mist-gently-drifting-1462227833-stockpack-adobestock
Lush green cloud forest vegetation with mist gently drifting through the trees, illustrating Ecuador's diverse ecosystems and natural beauty.

NYU Law School Clinic Attempting to Obtain Copyright for a Forest

The claim is that the forest is the co-creator of a song in which nature sounds are used
Like so much of contemporary “nature rights” advocacy, this is nonsense. A forest does not have agency and can’t author anything. It is incapable of creative acts. Read More ›
newspaper-rock-state-historical-site-utah-detail-stockpack-a-171501661-stockpack-adobestock
Newspaper Rock State Historical Site, Utah, detail

How Many Random Blips Are Needed To Make a Human?

Just asking for a friend… no, seriously, a look at some recent news from human paleontology
Human origins papers are often informative and entertaining, as long as we do not confuse them with understanding the realities of human origins and experience. Read More ›
clarifying-complex-ideas-theme-with-light-bulb-flat-lay-stoc-619300211-stockpack-adobestock
Clarifying complex ideas theme with light bulb - Flat lay

Podcast: The Challenge of Proving Creativity in AI

AI researcher Mappouras discusses the limitations of the Lovelace test for AI creativity with host Robert Marks
Mappouras doesn’t rule out creativity in machines; he wants to develop a test that could recognize it. Read More ›
infant-chimpanzee-in-gombe-national-park-tanzania-stockpack-68913557-stockpack-adobestock
Infant chimpanzee in Gombe National Park, Tanzania

Was the Legendary Jane Goodall (1934–2025) the End of an Era?

Perhaps. A more realistic appraisal of the reality of human uniqueness is needed if we hope to prevent the extinction of chimpanzees in the wild
While Goodall believed that there is no sharp line dividing humans and chimpanzees, she herself was one of many who embodied the sharp line. Read More ›
african-animals-baboons-sleeping-high-in-trees-for-safety-hu-961832747-stockpack-adobestock
African animals, baboons sleeping, high in trees for safety, huddled together to keep warm during the cool night

Baboons as the New Humans: The Disney Effect at work

As a recent review in Science shows, the Disney Effect allows even research scientists to ignore the differences between animal minds and the human mind
The Arrogant Ape points its finger at humanity. But in truth, the arrogance lies in denying the obvious — and nearly universal — judgment of humanity. Read More ›
panoramic-view-of-the-earth-sun-star-and-galaxy-sunrise-over-194080021-stockpack-adobe_stock
Panoramic view of the Earth, sun, star and galaxy. Sunrise over planet Earth, view from space. Elements of this image furnished by NASA

Only Bioethics Can Save the Planet! Really?

Some bioethicists want to include “planetary health” among the disciplines for which they propose ethical rules
Hopefully, the growing hubris of bioethicists who think they can tackle the world’s most intractable problems — even war — will push them into irrelevance. Read More ›
this-image-portrays-anthropomorphized-dogs-and-cats-dressed-714199582-stockpack-adobestock
This image portrays anthropomorphized dogs and cats dressed in vintage clothing, engaged in a serious game of poker in an old-fashioned room.Gambling concept. AI generated.

Animals Taught Us Culture Though They Don’t Have It Themselves?

Researchers tie themselves into some odd knots trying to demonstrate that humans are just like other life forms
There seems no sense of embarrassment over claims that defy evidence — so long as the reality of human exceptionalism is trashed. Read More ›
heartwarming-interaction-between-children-and-chimpanzee-sho-1216915021-stockpack-adobestock
Heartwarming interaction between children and chimpanzee showcasing human animal bond in zoo setting

Do Humans and Chimpanzees Differ by Only 1 Percent?

Of course not, but now that a more likely genetics figure has been published, some researchers are having a surprisingly hard time accepting it
15%? Whew. Genetics makes a difference in how life forms look and act… So Crick and Watson, Collins and Venter and all the rest were onto something after all… Read More ›
human-skull-desertification-climate-change-drought-death-ari-849124953-stockpack-adobestock
Human Skull Desertification Climate Change Drought Death Arid Land Environmental Crisis

IVF Clinic Bomber Infected by Anti-Humanism

According to media reports, Bartkus, who died at the scene, was a “‘pro-mortalist’ (believing death is preferable to living) or an ‘anti-natalist’ (believing no more human beings should be born).”
Culturally accepted human-phobia can be dangerous. There are mentally unbalanced people out there who don’t see misanthropy as merely an intellectual mind game. Read More ›
spaceship-flies-near-the-amazing-blue-planet-earth-view-from-419506789-stockpack-adobestock
Spaceship flies near the amazing blue planet earth, view from the window. Travel and tourists in space, concept. Beautiful space view of the Earth with cloud formation. Hotel in space

A Challenge to Pale Blue Dot-ology: Earth Is Significant

The “pale blue dot lost in space” view of Earth seems to brand science as an intellectual property of materialist atheism. And evidence isn’t what keeps it going
Perhaps more of us should start calling out these assumptions that arise not from observing nature but from the intellectual commitments of those who make them. Read More ›
mushroom-growing-in-a-landscape-of-a-strange-exoplanet-stock-770687529-stockpack-adobestock
Mushroom growing in a landscape of a strange exoplanet

ET Doesn’t Need to Exist in Order to Do His Real Job

His real job seems to be to support a lame argument about why humans are not exceptional. But the very idea of his existence works just as well
The search for ET itself does the philosophical work of attempting to deflate human “self-importance.” Finding anything is a bonus. Read More ›
alien-planet-landscape-beautiful-forest-the-surface-of-an-exoplanet-stockpack-adobe-stock.jpg
alien planet landscape, beautiful forest the surface of an exoplanet

Why Life Beyond Earth Would Prove Human Exceptionalism

A science writer thinks that finding life on other planets in our galaxy would somehow put a dent in our “self-importance”
Actually, human minds created sophisticated instruments that project our understanding light years away, using the scientific method that we created. Read More ›
a-human-head-with-glowing-neurons-in-the-brain-generative-ai-561842189-stockpack-adobestock
A human head with glowing neurons in the brain. Generative AI

The Nature of Mind, Free Will, and Human Uniqueness: A Deep Dive

The book Minding the Brain sparks some interesting discussions about what is really unique about the human mind
Many philosophers have concluded both from experience and careful consideration that mental phenomena cannot be reduced to neural mechanisms. Read More ›
highly-detailed-close-up-portrait-of-an-adult-raven-in-yello-413695912-stockpack-adobestock
Highly detailed close up portrait of an adult Raven in Yellowstone National Park, species name Corvus corax

At Quanta: High Bird Intelligence Developed on a Different Path

High intelligence developing on different paths is consistent with convergent evolution. It’s also consistent with design in nature
It is ironic that otherwise intelligent people must play the “we’re just another animal” game while demanding attention for ideas that only humans can give. Read More ›
a-post-apocalyptic-cityscape-devoid-of-life-with-crumbling-b-772759114-stockpack-adobe_stock
A post-apocalyptic cityscape devoid of life, with crumbling buildings, overgrown vegetation, and the remnants of civilization scattered throughout the desolate landscape, Generative AI

At a Science Journal: Humanity Is Just So Doomed

Opinions differ as to the details of what will wipe us all out — or maybe not
In one version, the coming human eclipse originated in a sin against Darwinism: destroying the competition. Read More ›
abstract-bacteria-probiotics-gram-positive-bacteria-bacteria-529671593-stockpack-adobe_stock
Abstract bacteria, probiotics, gram positive bacteria bacteria and viruses of various shapes against a light background. Concept of science, medicine. Microbiology background. 3d illustration.

In Moral Terms, Are Microbes More Important Than People?

Jeff Sebo advocates widening the moral circle to include, plants, microbes, and computers in a sort of radical equality
With all the talk of morality, I was particularly struck by a category of moral “patients” he fails to discuss: gestating human babies. Read More ›
front-view-portrait-of-cute-african-american-girl-lying-on-b-476005085-stockpack-adobe_stock
Front view portrait of cute African-American girl lying on bed with big pet dog and smiling, copy space

Clinical Psychologist Defends Human Exceptionalism

Gregg Henriques is responding to an evolutionary biologist who sees recognition of human uniqueness as “speciesism,” akin to racism and sexism
From a secular humanist perspective, he says roughly what Aristotle (384– 322 BC) and Thomas Aquinas (1225–1274) would say about our unique human nature. Read More ›
bonobos-in-natural-habitat-green-natural-background-stockpac-132588326-stockpack-adobe_stock
Bonobos in natural habitat. Green natural background.

Defining an Ape Theory of Mind Into Existence

We are told that “recognizing when someone else lacks information” has been thought to be a distinctly human trait. Really?
The researchers have set out to show that bonobos have a theory of mind. Are they willing to consider that dogs might have a similar theory of mind? Read More ›
four-silhouettes-of-people-looking-at-the-night-sky-with-a-t-1069933367-stockpack-adobe_stock
Four silhouettes of people looking at the night sky with a telescope.

Vice President Vance Defends Human Exceptionalism at Munich

The idea that humans are special is under increasing attack by some of society’s most powerful political and cultural forces
Oppression, genocide, discrimination, slavery, and other evils arise from refusing to see us all as equals based upon our common humanity. Read More ›