Mind Matters Natural and Artificial Intelligence News and Analysis

Monthly Archive October 2025

wide-angle-shot-of-a-campus-science-building-with-futuristic-918194105-stockpack-adobestock
Wide angle shot of a campus science building with futuristic design, students in lab coats walking in and out, energetic vibe

What Happens When Science Degenerates Into a Spoils System?

Chemistry prof Anna Krylov forces us to look at that in discouraging detail
Krylov also calls out the practices of choosing citations on the basis of social justice merit instead of relevance and of censoring awkward findings. Read More ›
will-rogers-stockpack-adobe-stock-36846391-stockpack-adobestock
Will Rogers

Scaling Up is Not Going to Make Large Language Models Intelligent

ChatGPT-5 misunderstood the jab in a simple Will Rogers joke five out of six times
Bigger data centers are not going to change the harsh reality that LLMs are prone to generating unreliable blather. Read More ›
spacecraft-orbiting-the-moon-with-earth-glowing-in-the-backg-1596067086-stockpack-adobestock
spacecraft orbiting the Moon with Earth glowing in the background. Stunning view of space exploration, lunar surface, and advanced satellite technology in outer space

Space travel: The future is slowly becoming everyday reality

Catch the vibe at COSM 2025. Oh, and we’ll also be talking about the national debt…
Relativity Space likes to call itself a “customer-centric rocket company.” When we hear a tag line like that, we know times have changed. Read More ›
young-man-reading-a-book-stockpack-adobe-stock-336067856-stockpack-adobestock
Young man reading a book

On the State of Men and Reading

Valuable advice to students: Learn how to read deeply
Reading great books might not immediately come to mind, but according to professor Shilo Brooks, it just might be a part of the answer. Read More ›
small-pile-rocks-sitting-top-body-deep-natural-background-gr-766076962-stockpack-adobestock
small pile rocks sitting top body deep natural background green robe plant harmony reflection refraction swirling gardens bamboo wood attribution centered horizon immortality fountain

Surprisingly Polite Response to Non-Materialist Book on the Mind

The discussion with well-known skeptic Michael Shermer and leading neuroscientist Christof Koch was notably polite and productive
Twenty years ago, materialism was expected to explain everything; now, more people are looking for broader picture answers. Read More ›
spiral-aloe-vera-with-water-drops-closeup-stockpack-adobe-st-654966076-stockpack-adobestock
Spiral aloe vera with water drops, closeup

Wikipedia Qualifies Its “Pseudoscience” Label re Design in Nature

Not only that but newly launched Grokipedia’s entry seems to be written to actually inform the reader rather than to enlist the reader against the topic
On ID, it sounds like Grokipedia, unlike Wikipedia, follows the time-honored rule of letting people explain themselves and saving the commentary for later. Read More ›
chat-gpt-artificial-intelligence-copy-writing-bot-by-open-ai-611480062-stockpack-adobestock
Chat GPT Artificial Intelligence copy writing bot by Open AI. Robot for student homework, education.

Large Language Models: Inconsistent Because They’re Unintelligent

Here’s what happened when I tested popular LLMs on student exercise questions I have been using for over fifty years
Claims that an LLM is intelligent don’t square with the fact that it may answer a question one way and, a few seconds later, simply contradict itself. Read More ›
delicious-golden-and-fluffy-cornbread-pieces-artfully-stacke-1573367907-stockpack-adobestock
Delicious, golden, and fluffy cornbread pieces, artfully stacked, enticing a feeling of warmth and comfort

Monday Micro Softy 50: Cutting Through the Cornbread

How did Yuri Senior cut the cornbread into eight identical portions using only three straight cuts?
You can guess the answer to Microsofty 49 if you try the test question yourself at home, using a small mirror. Read More ›
ethereal-gaia-goddess-portrait-amidst-lush-foliage-stockpack-814919199-stockpack-adobestock
Ethereal Gaia Goddess Portrait Amidst Lush Foliage

Totalitarian ‘Nature Rights’ Legislation in U.K. House of Lords

This is the most draconian and potentially tyrannical “nature rights” proposal I have yet seen
This bill vividly illustrates the authoritarian impulses of the “nature rights” movement specifically and its embrace of toxic anti-humanism generally. Read More ›
woman-praying-and-free-the-birds-flying-on-sunset-background-145584909-stockpack-adobestock
Woman praying and free the birds flying on sunset background, hope concept

Pure Unlimited Love: Faith, Freedom, and the Path to Peace

To illustrate the nature of the qualities needed, Dr. Post shared with Dr. Egnor a moving story from his time working in a geriatric psychiatric hospital in Mount Vernon, Ohio
Dr. Egnor agreed, observing that the United States seems to be losing its ability to hold respectful disagreement. Post responded by quoting Abraham Lincoln’s call for unity Read More ›
wall-street-stockpack-adobe-stock-9577728-stockpack-adobestock
Wall street

Wall Street Journal Takes On Science and the Existence of God

In an interview, first author of the new book out of France, Michel-Yves Bolloré, tells a WSJ editor, “We are now in a century where science is the best ally of God.” That’s news
With Bolloré and Bonnassies’ work, reality-based thinking is coming back. And the reality is that the universe offers much evidence for God. Read More ›
slippery-surface-warning-sign-stockpack-adobe-stock-7200480-stockpack-adobestock
Slippery surface warning sign

Assisted-Suicide Slippery Slope Keeps Slip-Sliding Away

“Strengthen safety,” and “fairer and more compassionate,” really just means more people can become dead much sooner
The ultimate destination for assisted suicide will be the creation of a fundamental right to be made dead, regardless of the reason, i.e., death on demand. Read More ›
aidriven-chatbots-assisting-customer-service-automated-commu-873108619-stockpack-adobestock
AIdriven chatbots assisting customer service, automated communication, concept

Will Reliance on AI Mean a Vast Drop in New Knowledge Production?

Dependence on AI assistants, for example, was found to greatly reduce discussion among peers, where new ideas are offered and evaluated
Ultimately, the AI knowledge system will be enriched or impoverished by human decisions, not by discovering a superintelligence. Read More ›
time-travel-jump-into-the-time-portal-in-hours-high-quality-559568866-stockpack-adobestock
Time travel. Jump into the time portal in hours. High quality illustration

The Pluses and the Perils of Time Travel in Science Fiction

Time travel can be treated as a form or hard or soft “magic” but it is important not to confuse the two
Soft magic is vague and incidental; hard magic imposes rules on the story. Too often in science fiction, these rules get broken. Read More ›
ultrasound-of-in-uterus-baby-at-22-weeks-healthy-baby-in-bel-130333454-stockpack-adobestock
Ultrasound of In Uterus Baby at 22 weeks. Healthy baby in belly.

Medical Journal Screed Decries All Fetal Personhood Laws

The authors imply that laws that protect unborn children are racist. But pro-lifers want more black babies born and protected from harm, not fewer
Embryology tells us that the unborn child is a human organism — distinct from but dependent upon his or her mother. Read More ›
facial-recognition-technology-to-monitor-the-population-on-b-608983195-stockpack-adobestock
Facial recognition technology to monitor the population on busy street. Generative AI

The Real Threat AI Poses to Us Is Created by Widespread Abuse

In If Anyone Builds It, Yudkowsky and Soares are not really grappling with this problem
The authors really believe in AI doom. Soares has stopped contributing to a retirement plan. I show that the serious problem is NOT superintelligence. Read More ›
hand-drawn-sketch-of-saint-petersburg-with-watercolor-old-ci-453471733-stockpack-adobestock
Hand drawn sketch of Saint-Petersburg with watercolor. Old city landscape

The Enduring Relevance of The Brothers Karamazov

Dostoevsky opposed materialism and pointed readers to beauty and mystery
The book may not present neat answers to our problems, but it presents a vital picture of what it looks like to cherish life and hold onto to the inherent value of human life. Read More ›
core-of-the-machine-3d-illustration-of-complex-futuristic-sc-259694908-stockpack-adobestock
Core of the machine / 3D illustration of complex futuristic science fiction brain nucleus machinery background

Can an AI Really Develop a Mind of Its Own?

Specifically, can an AI develop a mind with its own goals and desires, capable of plans and strategies — as the authors of If Anyone Builds It believe?
Even if we adopt a materialist view of the mind, I believe I can show why it is not possible for a machine to develop a mind. Read More ›
lush-green-cloud-forest-vegetation-with-mist-gently-drifting-1462227833-stockpack-adobestock
Lush green cloud forest vegetation with mist gently drifting through the trees, illustrating Ecuador's diverse ecosystems and natural beauty.

NYU Law School Clinic Attempting to Obtain Copyright for a Forest

The claim is that the forest is the co-creator of a song in which nature sounds are used
Like so much of contemporary “nature rights” advocacy, this is nonsense. A forest does not have agency and can’t author anything. It is incapable of creative acts. Read More ›
glowing-blue-large-question-mark-digital-network-design-abst-1314641083-stockpack-adobestock
Glowing blue large question mark, digital network design, abstract concept, symbolizes inquiry, problem-solving, technology, innovation, digital future

COSM 2025 Talk: Where Are We With AI Right Now? Really.

Recent developments should focus attention on Uli Homann's talk
Just as the AI industry is becoming more analytical and realistic about how best to use AI, some users are falling in love with chatbots. We need to know more. Read More ›