Mind Matters Natural and Artificial Intelligence News and Analysis

CategoryScience Fiction

fantastic-multicolored-outer-space-with-stars-constellations-570880608-stockpack-adobestock
fantastic multicolored outer space with stars, constellations, galaxies, planets and nebulae. Generative AI

Star Wars: The Force Awakens — Science Lessons vs. Story Rules

In Part 14 of my extended review of The Force Awakens, we look at the problem that unanswered practical questions creates for the audience

Special effects are not worthless but they are second-tier when it comes to storytelling.

Read More ›
person-light-woman-sunset-wave-contemplation-930123-pxhere.com

The Force Awakens Review Part 13

When she touches the lightsaber, she receives a vision

The particulars of this vision aren’t really important because they are just a bunch of teases that are disappointing but what is important is the number of questions raised around it.

Read More ›
dinosaurs-running-through-the-water-in-front-of-tropical-jun-813668415-stockpack-adobestock
dinosaurs running through the water in front of tropical jungle.

Dinosaurs, Meet Carl Sagan at the End of Oak Street

The film was marketed as a stupid dinosaur movie. In reality, it’s a movie about marriage, cleverly disguised as a stupid dinosaur movie.

The End of Oak Street never answers the God question and never directly contradicts Carl Sagan but it raises nagging questions.

Read More ›
blue-sunrise-view-of-earth-from-space-stockpack-adobe-stock
blue sunrise, view of earth from space

Star Wars – The Force Awakens: Review Part 11

Maz is basically saying that the light and the darkness are always rising up in different forms

The Force offers power, and, to maintain that power in a non-destructive manner, one must learn virtues and not give in to temptation.

Read More ›
Screws, bolts and nuts on metal background
Screws, bolts and nuts on metal background

Star Wars: The Force Awakens Review Part 10

Flying a ship and fixing a ship are two different skills

Flying a ship and fixing a ship are two different skills. They were able to patch the ship up well enough, but they couldn’t take care of the problem with the hyperdrive by themselves, which is why they went to Lando in the first place.

Read More ›
science-fiction-wallpaper-beauty-of-deep-space-colorful-grap-300644273-stockpack-adobestock
science fiction wallpaper. Beauty of deep space. Colorful graphics for background, like water waves, clouds, night sky, universe, galaxy, Planets,

Star Wars: The Force Awakens Review, Part 9

Three films’ worth of character development has been undone

Han tells Leia directly that he is in this for the money, not the revolution, which is not something a typical sleazy character would say.

Read More ›
cosmic-eye-macro-photo-of-a-hazel-eye-in-space-stockpack-ado-378633993-stockpack-adobestock
Cosmic Eye. Macro Photo of a Hazel Eye in Space

Star Wars: The Force Awakens Review Part 5

Science fiction often has various characters describing different social or philosophical positions

There are plenty of flawless or powerful characters in storytelling. Sherlock Holmes has flaws, but he is powerful in the respect that his intellect is unparalleled, and his character has defined a genre of storytelling.

Read More ›
red-eye-hal-stockpack-adobe-stock-51269601-stockpack-adobestock
red eye hal

2001: A Space Odyssey: It Comes Down at Last to Bowman vs. HAL

In Part 5, we see that both Clarke and Kubrick treat AI as a potential threat to humanity but for different reasons

A critical question for assessing the future of AI is, why did the space agency give HAL almost total control of the ship.

Read More ›
view-of-the-surface-of-the-moonelements-of-this-image-furnis-526845599-stockpack-adobestock
View of the surface of the moon.Elements of this image furnished by NASA

2001: A Space Odyssey: The Brief Story of Heywood Floyd

In Part 4, we look at what the middle story — meeting the Monolith on the moon — is doing

We don’t really get to see enough of HAL 9000 when he is actually a help to the space travelers, which reduces the impact of his turn.

Read More ›
sci-fi-modern-concrete-cement-futuristic-garage-empty-space-400446759-stockpack-adobestock
Sci Fi Modern Concrete Cement Futuristic Garage Empty Space whith metallic monolith, 3D Rendering illustration

Space Odyssey 2001: Were Clarke and Kubrick at Odds?

Part 3: The ambiguity in 2001 is not the result of artistic muddiness but the middle ground for an unspoken conflict between the two writers

One thing is for certain. In the iconic Dawn of Man sequence, the Monolith is conveying information. The question is how.

Read More ›
black-stone-monolith-in-ancient-jungle-portal-or-a-sign-of-c-577826792-stockpack-adobestock
Black stone monolith in ancient jungle, portal or a sign of civilisation. Generative AI

Space Odyssey 2001: Decisions To Make About That Monolith

In Part 2 of my series on the sci-fi great, I want to consider where the Monolith fits in the hard vs. soft magic systems that make for sci-fi stories

Letting the question of who sent the monolith remain a mystery was probably a wise dramatic choice on the part of the writers.

Read More ›
nature-photograph-of-tall-skinny-vantablack-monolith-on-a-fl-578520405-stockpack-adobestock
nature photograph of tall, skinny vantablack monolith on a flat glacier AI-Generated

2001: A Space Odyssey Was a New Type of Science Fiction

The film is perhaps best understood as three completely different stories whose only connection is the monolith

The greatest measure of a film’s success is the test of time. Something about this film works even though it breaks conventions.

Read More ›
man-on-time-machine-best-resolution-stockpack-adobe-stock-626710155-stockpack-adobestock
Man on time machine. Best resolution

How To Write a Time Travel Story That Keeps Making Sense: Part 2

In this sixth and final installment, I show how narrowing a rather than escalating it, avoids unwanted paradoxes

Escalation is where the Terminator franchise went wrong. The writers kept enlarging their world until it became contradictory.

Read More ›
the-butterfly-sucks-mud-water-in-the-gemsbok-national-park-k-208212020-stockpack-adobestock
The butterfly sucks mud water in the gemsbok national park, Kalahari South Africa

How To Write a Time Travel Story That Keeps Making Sense, Part 1

Here in Part 5, I offer an approach that allows for time travel without obvious giant plot holes

To keep the story under control, the time machine itself should be a hard system even if the concept of time is soft and pliable.

Read More ›
time-travel-in-different-dimensions-ai-generated-stockpack-a-569288283-stockpack-adobestock
Time travel in different dimensions. AI generated.

Time Travel in Science Fiction: Now For Some Examples That Work…

Here in Part 4, we look at how to make time travel work as either soft or hard magic

Time travel into the future is not as tricky as travel into the past because altering the future does not create so many complex story problems.

Read More ›
space-of-time-dimension-conceptuniverseillusiontime-theory-s-816704682-stockpack-adobestock
space of time dimension concept,universe,illusion,time theory

Time Travel: The Threat of Escalation in the Terminator Series

Part 3: The Terminator series writers never new whether there would be a sequel, and that had implications for how they plotted time travel

Shrouding the story rules in mystery only works with soft magic systems where the story focus is on something other than the system.

Read More ›