Mind Matters Natural and Artificial Intelligence News and Analysis

CategoryScience

tide-going-out-on-beach-in-mexico-at-sunset-with-mountains-b-391796205-stockpack-adobe_stock
Tide going out on beach in Mexico at sunset with mountains behind

Woke SciAm Editor Resigns in Post-US Election Uproar

Michael Shermer, founding publisher of Skeptic Magazine and former Scientific American columnist, offers a thoughtful response

Shermer writes, “the people promulgating these woke ideas are mostly true believers” and their fervor makes it easier to convince themselves, not others.

Read More ›
consensus-word-made-of-square-letter-block-on-green-square-m-233406584-stockpack-adobe_stock
Consensus word made of square letter block on green square mat background.

Nature Editorial Attacks Trump for Ignoring “Scientific Consensus”

Mistrust of the state, which the editorialists fear, doesn’t weaken democracy. It is essential to its proper functioning. Hence the Constitution and Bill of Rights

Nature, a British publication, should stay out of American politics; otherwise, it breeds the very mistrust of the science sector that it decries.

Read More ›
a-captivating-view-of-a-black-hole-in-space-a-dark-center-su-835035920-stockpack-adobe_stock
A captivating view of a black hole in space, a dark center surrounded by a swirling disk of hot, glowing gas and dust, stars and nebulae in the background being bent by its gravity, feeling of the

Did Stephen Hawking End His Career by Giving Up on Truth?

A philosopher argues the case. But has the rejection of truth in physics spread widely into popular culture?

One element of getting to choose our private truths is that we need only notice or understand the significance of the things we want to notice or understand.

Read More ›
hyper-realistic-figure-standing-at-a-forked-road-with-incred-1012775102-stockpack-adobe_stock
Hyper-realistic figure standing at a forked road, with incredible detail in the environment, representing free will in a realistic scene

Free Will: A Materialist Thinks It Might Somehow Be Real

Psychiatrist Ralph Lewis thinks that Darwinian evolution can explain human consciousness but now hesitates to debunk free will

Earlier this year, University of Toronto psychiatrist Ralph Lewis wrote a two-part series at Psychology Today titled “The Strongest Neuroscience Arguments in the Free Will Debate” (here and here). He looked at Mitchell (yes) and Sapolsky (no), both of whom published serious books on the topic in 2023. And he concluded, For now, for practical purposes, given our current level of incomplete understanding of the complexities of the brain’s decision-making processes, and our inability to predict human behaviors in most situations, we might as well regard ourselves as having free will—or rather, degrees of freedom. We do know that our brain has highly evolved systems for self-control—even for those of us who struggle with this relatively more than others, and Read More ›

old-books-background-stockpack-adobe-stock-40572208-stockpack-adobe_stock
old books background

Rodney Stark: A Historian Finds a History Amid Cultural Myths

As his views matured, Stark found himself more and more opposed to the nineteenth-century positivist founders of social science

Stark, reappraising the role of religion, found that seeing history through a positivist, materialist lens reduces its complexities to caricatures.

Read More ›
evangelist-hello-name-tag-sticker-supporter-preacher-3d-illu-196438150-stockpack-adobe_stock
Evangelist Hello Name Tag Sticker Supporter Preacher 3d Illustration

Richard Dawkins as an Unlikely Evangelist

As a recent book of essays demonstrates, the once much-vaunted new atheism spurred many thinking people to become Christians

Leading atheist philosophers have found Dawkins’s arguments superficial, many find his “warfare” thesis against religion shallow and his certitude unjustified.

Read More ›
flags-of-palestine-and-israel-painted-on-cracked-wall-stockp-199344623-stockpack-adobe_stock
flags of Palestine and Israel painted on cracked wall

Top Journal Nature Promotes Views of Anti-Israel Demonstrator

What any of this has to do with promoting science is beyond me. It’s politics and ideology, pure and simple. Perhaps that’s why the interview is not behind a paywall

The editors of Nature are destroying a once venerable and important science journal. That’s bad for science, which is bad for the world. Shame.

Read More ›
high-tech-american-election-coverage-in-a-futuristic-studio-972672861-stockpack-adobe_stock
High-tech American election coverage in a futuristic studio

Presidential Pundits—a P-Hacking Parable

In politics, as elsewhere, too many studies flop when other researchers attempt to replicate them with fresh data

Some prediction models were developed by well-intentioned researchers before the perils of p-hacking were clearly understood, hence the failures.

Read More ›
big-bang-stockpack-adobe-stock-98473600-stockpack-adobe_stock

After Dawkins Is Canceled, What Comes Next? Not Better Science!

As the National Academies of Science try to blend traditional lore into science findings, the concept of truth that atheists and theists clash over is irrelevant

For many today, truth is whatever benefits Woke causes. Claims for truth that offer them no political benefit are seen as a threat, meriting a hostile response.

Read More ›
robot-reading-book-and-solving-math-data-analytics-concept-o-765127551-stockpack-adobe_stock
robot reading book and solving math data analytics, concept of future mathematics artificial intelligence

Is True Artificial Intelligence Possible? A Science Perspective

Many will conclude that true AI — AI that thinks like humans — must be possible because we hear so much about it from so many sources

Experiments like ARC–AGI have finally made true computer intelligence into a scientifically respectable theory, because AI can now be falsified.

Read More ›
politician-during-election-campaign-stockpack-adobe-stock-330827148-stockpack-adobe_stock
Politician during election campaign

Science Writer Tells Top Science Mag: Quit Endorsing Politicians!

Scientific American's display of political partisanship comes at an awkward time. Trust in science is in steady, ongoing decline

When scientists engage in political partisanship, they abandon accuracy, regarding their choice a form of righteousness as long as the Good party wins.

Read More ›
a-political-rally-with-protest-signs-stockpack-adobe-stock-781252043-stockpack-adobe_stock
A political rally with protest signs

The Science Establishment Continues to Politicize “Science”

And that ain’t good for science

Increasingly, those who claim to be science’s greatest defenders do the sector wrong by becoming highly ideological and progressively partisan.

Read More ›
a-group-of-sheep-on-a-pasture-stand-next-to-each-other-and-look-into-the-camera-stockpack-adobe-stock
a group of sheep on a pasture stand next to each other and look into the camera

Engineer Explains Why AI Bots Always Lean Left

ChatGPT kept insisting on scientific consensus as the most important factor in what to believe regarding global warming and similar issues

If AI systems such as ChatGPT cannot engage in conceptual thought, then they can only promote consensus, which is what we see.

Read More ›
laboratory-technician-checking-cdc-specimen-submitting-form-laboratory-testing-for-sars-cov-2-covid-19-coronavirus-disease-infectionglobal-pandemic-crisisswab-collection-patient-specimen-procedure-stockpack-adobe-stock
Laboratory technician checking CDC specimen submitting form, laboratory testing for SARS-CoV-2 COVID-19 Coronavirus disease infection,global pandemic crisis,swab collection patient specimen procedure

COVID: A Lab Leak — the Most Likely Cause — Is Not Discussible

Although COVID killed approximately 28 million people, the Chinese government makes discussion of its origin very difficult, says Matt Ridley

The science world has come to depend on China a great deal — for money, among other things — and dare not risk giving offense by unwanted discussion.

Read More ›
old-egyptian-hieroglyphs-with-ufo-aliens-on-ancient-background-concept-humanoid-flying-saucer-history-of-earth-generation-ai-stockpack-adobe-stock
Old Egyptian hieroglyphs with UFO Aliens on ancient background. Concept humanoid Flying saucer history of Earth. Generation AI

Are Beliefs in Space Aliens Really Spiraling Out of Control?

A British philosophy prof sees such views as a “widespread societal problem,” comparing them to the J6 riot

On the whole, Milligan’s worries are not so much unreasonable as they are perennial. People will NOT easily accept that we might be alone in the universe.

Read More ›
the-combination-of-playing-cards-stockpack-adobe-stock
The combination of playing cards

Darwin’s Bold Bluff: He Never Demonstrated His Evolution Theory

He often promised he would demonstrate it. But, as Robert Shedinger shows, when he didn’t, his supporters decided to just act like he had

Their strategy worked quite well because, by gentleman’s agreement, everyone closed ranks and no one asked hard questions — until quite recently…

Read More ›
large-language-model-ai-machine-learning-concept-brain-business-stockpack-adobe-stock
large language model AI machine learning concept brain business

A Sloppy “AI Scientist” Could Make the Science Crisis Much Worse

A research team claims to have developed the AI Scientist that “generates novel research ideas, writes code, executes experiments ...” Really?

It continues to astonish us how easily people can be persuaded that LLMs (chatbots) can do our thinking for us

Read More ›
y-chromosome-on-dark-background-blue-color-3d-illustration-stockpack-adobe-stock
Y chromosome on dark background. Blue color. 3d illustration.

Biologist Kicked Out of National Institutes of Health Event

Colin Wright and Tomas Bogardus, also ejected, deny being disruptive but both think that humans are sex binary. That may have been enough

In a world of private truth that owes nothing to either faith or science, dissenting opinion is an invasion from an alien universe. Stay safe by not hearing.

Read More ›
stylish-composition-of-home-garden-interior-filled-a-lot-of-beautiful-plants-cacti-succulents-air-plant-in-different-design-pots-home-gardening-concept-home-jungle-copy-spcae-template-stockpack-adobe-stock
Stylish composition of home garden interior filled a lot of beautiful plants, cacti, succulents, air plant in different design pots. Home gardening concept Home jungle. Copy spcae. Template

Philosopher Hollers Whoa! Are Plants Really Conscious?

Pigliucci worries about the claim. But if human consciousness 1) exists and 2) is fully natural, some scientists would of course argue that plants share it

Darwinism’s failure to simply *eliminate* the human mind, as promised, enabled a Pandora’s box of materialist claims for consciousness in all life forms.

Read More ›
dystopian-metropolis-film-noir-gothic-style-industrial-architecture-landscape-image-stockpack-adobe-stock
Dystopian metropolis. Film noir gothic style industrial architecture landscape image

If Materialism Is Failing, What Replaces It Might Not Be Better

If panpsychism prevails, we may need to get used to the politics of Insect Rights and of Rocks' Lives Matter. Also, panpsychists may have little of consequence to say about freedom of thought

The concern Michael Egnor expresses, that materialism, while barren, may be replaced by something worse, may be prescient, depending on how panpsychism unfolds.

Read More ›