Mind Matters Natural and Artificial Intelligence News and Analysis

CategoryEducation

happy-diverse-school-children-students-group-building-roboti-455006173-stockpack-adobestock
Happy diverse school children students group building robotic vehicle robot cars using tablet computer education software apps. Kids learning programming sit at table at STEM coding engineering class.

Educating the Tech Workforce: A Powerhouse Panel

Former Arizona governor Doug Ducey introduced statewide school choice and since then, sixteen states have followed suit
Together, Ducey, Ingraham, and Clark made a robust and compelling case at COSM for education freedom, with Ducey framing it as a matter of fairness. Read More ›
a-child-holding-a-tablet-with-a-chatbot-interface-on-the-scr-1152739883-stockpack-adobestock
A child holding a tablet with a chatbot interface on the screen, showing colorful icons and a cheerful robot character.

Kids and Chatbots: How Dissenting Views Got Me Disinvited

As a lifelong software engineer, I am an insider on a topic like this and I know that their programming makes them unsuitable for children
I also believe that their programmed tendency to lead to addictive relationships makes them unsuitable for adults as well but that’s another topic. Read More ›
helmeted-members-of-a-little-league-baseball-team-sitting-on-617810574-stockpack-adobestock
Helmeted members of a little league baseball team sitting on the team bench waiting to hit, daytime, sunny

What We Can Learn About Schooling From Baseball

In Part 3, drawing on my experience as a baseball coach, I offer a somewhat different approach to using AI in education
Edify kids, don’t enhance them. We are organic beings, not gadgets to be improved with newer and better modules (like the newest computer chips). Read More ›
a-smiling-teacher-assists-elementary-school-students-using-c-1662462033-stockpack-adobestock
** A smiling teacher assists elementary school students using Chromebooks in a bright, colorful classroom. Technology integration in modern education is evident. **

How AI Could Create Vast Increases in Learning Efficiency

Part 2: Artificial intelligence is promising to fundamentally transform education, leading to vast increases in efficiency of learning
Alpha School students are said to advance an average of 2.6× faster than peers on nationally normed MAP (Measures of Academic Progress) tests and frequently score in the 99th percentile. Read More ›
futuristic-scholar-teen-girl-in-school-ambience-generative-a-627837675-stockpack-adobestock
Futuristic Scholar teen Girl in School Ambience, generative ai

A Non-Transhumanist Vision for AI in Education

Bill Dembski describes this new approach as amounting to edification rather than enhancement
AI should be used as a way of honing students’ skills and knowledge, helping them learn more effectively than before. Read More ›
custom-library-stockpack-adobe-stock-220293246-stockpack-adobestock
Custom library

Thanks to Our Screens, We’re Heading For a Post-Literate Culture?

Whatever one’s opinions regarding solutions for declining literacy rates, people can always start to brew change in their own lives and communities
Ted Gioia writes, books “offer an escape from the degraded digital domains, where duplicity is now dictated by the largest platforms with the richest owners.” Read More ›
robot-writing-in-book-for-large-language-model-and-artificia-1230823708-stockpack-adobestock
robot writing in book for large language model and artificial intelligence chatbot concept

Students Beware: AI Copilot Admits Errors But Won’t Correct Them

Parents and teachers must beware when students treat AI research as accurate; I myself was misled while writing this article!
But here’s the punchline: I was wrong on an important point and Copilot let me stay wrong! Read More ›
education-kid-learning-and-training-with-ai-knowledge-and-te-1568784515-stockpack-adobestock
Education, kid learning and training with AI, knowledge and technology concept. Robot hologram in graduation hat showing while child using digital tablet with finger touch on screen, homework school.

AI in Education: Is the System Being Gamed — or the Student?

AI makes it easier to game the system, but many users are also being gamed
Users, whose output is used to train the AI systems, will pay higher electricity costs on account of them while experts eventually earn top salaries. Read More ›
amazed-young-woman-student-in-denim-clothes-eyeglasses-backp-322157060-stockpack-adobestock
Amazed young woman student in denim clothes, eyeglasses, backpack posing isolated on pastel pink background. Education in high school university college concept. Holding books, scream in megaphone.

Campus Civil Rights Advocate: Free Speech Makes Us Safer

Greg Lukianoff stresses the importance of listening to people to know what they think
His new book, co-authored with Nadine Strossen, offers ten arguments against free speech — and why they fail. Read More ›
a-bustling-university-or-college-environment-where-students-626511967-stockpack-adobestock
A bustling university or college environment where students are seen walking to their classes. Generative AI

Which Way, Modern University? Jennifer Frey’s story

The shakeup at the University of Tulsa’s Honors College is a puzzler
She's been fired, despite the huge success of her classic books program, which is now “going in a different direction.” Read More ›
unrecognizable-woman-student-using-chat-bot-on-laptop-stockp-707237992-stockpack-adobestock
Unrecognizable woman student using chat bot on laptop

How To Avoid AIM — the AI Moron Effect

The popularity of getting chatbots to produce assignments may be a signal that college doesn't matter as much as it used to

A recent article by James D. Walsh at New York magazine worries that AI is dooming education — such as it is these days. In January 2023, just two months after OpenAI launched ChatGPT, a survey of 1,000 college students found that nearly 90 percent of them had used the chatbot to help with homework assignments. In its first year of existence, ChatGPT’s total monthly visits steadily increased month-over-month until June, when schools let out for the summer. (That wasn’t an anomaly: Traffic dipped again over the summer in 2024.) Professors and teaching assistants increasingly found themselves staring at essays filled with clunky, robotic phrasing that, though grammatically flawless, didn’t sound quite like a college student — or even a Read More ›

man-and-ai-robot-waiting-for-a-job-interview-ai-vs-human-com-680701487-stockpack-adobestock
Man and AI robot waiting for a job interview: AI vs human competition

The Job Market is Telling Us Something About AI and Jobs…

But it’s not telling us the same things as the AI hypesters are telling us
The job market for recent college grads may be warning us that participation trophies for college and ChatGPT use have long-run costs. Read More ›
intriguing-brain-teaser-game-long-exposure-photo-of-abstract-1170926241-stockpack-adobestock
Intriguing Brain Teaser Game: Long Exposure Photo of Abstract Puzzle Pieces

Is the Reverse Flynn Effect — Declining Intelligence — Real?

IQ tests were never meant to measure memorization or familiarity, yet that’s precisely what’s happening
What we now call “intelligence” has gradually become detached from the embodied, contextualized reasoning that characterized earlier generations. Read More ›
a-high-tech-classroom-of-the-future-with-students-using-augm-1072551128-stockpack-adobestock
A high-tech classroom of the future, with students using augmented reality glasses. School.

Ohio State to Require Students to Learn “AI Fluency”

The university is embracing, rather than rejecting, AI

If you can’t beat ’em, join ’em? Ohio State University recently announced that each of its students must take an AI skills class starting in the Fall of 2025. Micaiah Bilger of The College Fix reports, Every undergraduate major at Ohio State will include classes that incorporate “AI Fluency,” NBC 4 WCMH reports. The public university’s leaders have developed a strategy that they believe will equip students to use the technology both creatively and responsibly. As AI continues to shape and disrupt higher education, administrators and teachers have to grapple with how to deal with this powerful technology. Many reports, personal testimonies, and commentary illustrates how much students today depend on AI systems like ChatGPT to do their assignments. Professors, meanwhile, Read More ›

leisure-creative-writing-prompts-cozy-writing-nook-with-a-ty-839700092-stockpack-adobestock
Leisure creative writing prompts, Cozy writing nook with a typewriter

NYT Journalist: The “Download” Model of Knowledge is Flawed

We learn by wrestling with ideas, by paying attention and making connections.
Humans aren’t computers. We are persons, centers of consciousness, who have physical bodies and come from particular contexts. Read More ›
group-of-youth-absorbed-in-smartphone-screens-stockpack-adob-920303413-stockpack-adobestock
Group of youth absorbed in smartphone screens

LLMs Are Bad at Good Things, Good at Bad Things

LLMs may well become smarter than humans in the near future but not because these chatbots are becoming more intelligent
As people become attached to and dependent on their AI friends, they become less interested in their fellow humans. Read More ›
technology-library-student-learning-concept-stockpack-adobe-133489778-stockpack-adobestock
Technology Library Student Learning Concept

Does AI Expose Colleges’ Underlying Problem?

AI could be a symptom of a deeper issue in higher education
The tragedy about AI is that those who depend on it to "think" for them won't have the work ethic, skill, or wisdom to offer value to the world. Read More ›
search-engine-optimization-seo-background-cover-the-concept-of-optimization-to-raise-the-position-of-the-site-the-search-engine-for-user-queries-network-traffic-in-the-search-engine-stockpack-adobe-stock
Search engine optimization, SEO, background cover, the concept of optimization to raise the position of the site, the search engine for user queries, network traffic in the search engine.

Becoming a Slave to Google: How It Happens

Part 4: After an update, you always have to second guess what Google did. You become a reverse engineer who never sees under the hood
This leads to a mentality that always tries to second guess whether Google will favor some piece of content or way of expressing it. Read More ›
unrecognizable-woman-student-using-chat-bot-on-laptop-stockp-707237992-stockpack-adobestock
Unrecognizable woman student using chat bot on laptop

Yes, Large Language Models May Soon be Smarter than Humans…

But not for the reason you think
Too many students are not learning how to think and write; they are learning how to use LLMs — no matter that LLM responses cannot be trusted. Read More ›