Mind Matters Natural and Artificial Intelligence News and Analysis

CategoryPhilosophy

a-captivating-view-of-a-black-hole-in-space-a-dark-center-su-835035920-stockpack-adobe_stock
A captivating view of a black hole in space, a dark center surrounded by a swirling disk of hot, glowing gas and dust, stars and nebulae in the background being bent by its gravity, feeling of the

Did Stephen Hawking End His Career by Giving Up on Truth?

A philosopher argues the case. But has the rejection of truth in physics spread widely into popular culture?
One element of getting to choose our private truths is that we need only notice or understand the significance of the things we want to notice or understand. Read More ›
if-then-logic-statement-written-in-white-chalk-on-a-black-ch-158992790-stockpack-adobe_stock
If Then logic statement written in white chalk on a black chalkboard isolated on white

Billboard Chris Asks a Sharp Question About “Evolution”

On a logical basis, Elston’s critique is unanswerable — but logic no longer has the status that it once did. Nor does evidence.
It may be that the big Whatever You Feel of private truth is here to stay and will slowly devour all forms of knowledge based on public truth. Read More ›
masculinity-a-gigantic-and-unmovable-weight-chained-to-a-vul-566523970-stockpack-adobe_stock
Masculinity - a gigantic and unmovable weight chained to a vulnerable and suffering person in pain, misery and helplessness. Cold and tragic condition created by Masculinity ,3d illustration

Philosopher Asks, Why the Toxic War on Masculinity?

Prominent evangelical philosopher Nancy Pearcey is teaching a course on the roots of the “hate men” movement today. Here’s an excerpt from the controversial book it's based on
Pearcey argues that the biblical view of manhood offers men far greater dignity than any secular view, especially the Darwinian one. Read More ›
retro-styled-image-of-old-pocket-watches-stockpack-adobe-sto-89359742-stockpack-adobe_stock
Retro styled image of old pocket watches

When Einstein Clashed With Philosopher Bergson Over Time

Bergson’s point, back in 1922, was that clocks, however accurate, don’t read themselves; they are interpreted by conscious beings
A recent experiment claimed to have identified negative time. If that’s true, solving one mystery in science opens up a vista of… more mysteries. Read More ›
big-bang-stockpack-adobe-stock-98473600-stockpack-adobe_stock

After Dawkins Is Canceled, What Comes Next? Not Better Science!

As the National Academies of Science try to blend traditional lore into science findings, the concept of truth that atheists and theists clash over is irrelevant
For many today, truth is whatever benefits Woke causes. Claims for truth that offer them no political benefit are seen as a threat, meriting a hostile response. Read More ›
the-confrontation-of-a-heatwave-and-a-melting-glacier-symbol-792041315-stockpack-adobe_stock
The confrontation of a heatwave and a melting glacier, symbolizing the collision of rising temperatures and shrinking ice masses. Concept of climate change impact on glaciers. Generative Ai.

New Atheism Is Shrinking and It’s Not Entirely Clear Why

Now, there is an eerie unfashionable silence that fashionable media are beginning to notice. For one thing, it is affecting Richard Dawkins
The Woke, it turns out, are no more tolerant of atheists than they are of anyone else with divergent views. That may be what finally fells new atheism. Read More ›
small-orange-flags-places-in-grass-in-memory-of-the-thousand-443404855-stockpack-adobe_stock
Small orange flags places in grass in memory of the thousands of Indigenous children that died in Canada's residential school system. Wide view.

Canada’s Residential Schools: A Saga of Journalistic Wrongdoing

Even as the story is collapsing for lack of evidence, there is a move afoot to criminalize doubt about what happened (denialism).
Could it happen in the United States? Of course. It can happen anywhere where people are willing to ignore the demands of evidence in favor of private truth. Read More ›
robot-reading-book-and-solving-math-data-analytics-concept-o-765127551-stockpack-adobe_stock
robot reading book and solving math data analytics, concept of future mathematics artificial intelligence

Is True Artificial Intelligence Possible? A Science Perspective

Many will conclude that true AI — AI that thinks like humans — must be possible because we hear so much about it from so many sources
Experiments like ARC–AGI have finally made true computer intelligence into a scientifically respectable theory, because AI can now be falsified. Read More ›
a-group-of-sheep-on-a-pasture-stand-next-to-each-other-and-look-into-the-camera-stockpack-adobe-stock
a group of sheep on a pasture stand next to each other and look into the camera

Engineer Explains Why AI Bots Always Lean Left

ChatGPT kept insisting on scientific consensus as the most important factor in what to believe regarding global warming and similar issues
If AI systems such as ChatGPT cannot engage in conceptual thought, then they can only promote consensus, which is what we see. Read More ›
flower-green-plant-stockpack-adobe-stock
Flower, Green, Plant

Haidt: Beauty and Awe Help Us Escape the Phone-Based Life

The question is: why are we drawn to beauty?
I want the beauty of the forest to actually be beautiful, not just signal a primordial drive to forage and hunt. Read More ›
dystopian-metropolis-film-noir-gothic-style-industrial-architecture-landscape-image-stockpack-adobe-stock
Dystopian metropolis. Film noir gothic style industrial architecture landscape image

If Materialism Is Failing, What Replaces It Might Not Be Better

If panpsychism prevails, we may need to get used to the politics of Insect Rights and of Rocks' Lives Matter. Also, panpsychists may have little of consequence to say about freedom of thought
The concern Michael Egnor expresses, that materialism, while barren, may be replaced by something worse, may be prescient, depending on how panpsychism unfolds. Read More ›
dna-sequence-generative-ai-stockpack-adobe-stock
DNA sequence. Generative AI

Biology Needs a Fresh Look — But Is It Afraid of What It’ll Find?

A science writer’s musings make clear that intelligent design is the only reasonable explanation for the human genome’s ordered complexity
But Philip Ball doesn’t want to go there and neither do most biologists — thus there are so many issues they just can’t raise. Read More ›
close-up-of-a-white-flower-with-water-in-the-foreground-and-a-blurred-background-to-the-right-of-the-image-stockpack-adobe-stock
Close-up of a white flower with water in the foreground and a blurred background to the right of the image

“Plant Philosophy” Denigrates Human Uniqueness

Much contemporary advocacy is obsessed with deconstructing human exceptionalism
Plant philosophy seeks to change the definitional understandings of “intelligence” to elevate the moral status of plants relative to humans. Read More ›
the-cells-of-the-body-are-being-attacked-by-bacteria-generative-ai-stockpack-adobe-stock
The cells of the body are being attacked by bacteria. Generative AI.

Physicists: Perhaps Life Is a Unique State of Matter

A physics gathering next week at the University of Rochester will explore the significance of the fact that life, unlike non-life, needs and uses information
One question the physicists must eventually tackle is, can agency come into existence without an Agent? And how can meaning exist in a mindless universe? Read More ›
plain-blank-detailed-dic-micrograph-of-a-single-celled-phacus-pleuronectes-euglenid-displaying-its-distinct-striated-pellicle-whip-like-flagellum-eyespot-paramylon-body-and-chloroplasts-stockpack-adobe-stock
plain blank Detailed DIC micrograph of a single-celled Phacus pleuronectes euglenid displaying its distinct striated pellicle, whip-like flagellum, eyespot, paramylon body, and chloroplasts

Dembski Asks the Chatbot: Is Intelligent Design Testable?

ChatGPT4o’s tour through the internet on the topic suggests that there may be some improvement in rational discussion out there
Many of the people who produce the material that the bot encounters desperately want to find ET and don’t want to find design. It still shows. Read More ›
ai-generated-view-of-the-multiverse-stockpack-adobe-stock
AI generated view of the multiverse

What Is Pseudoscience? A Philosopher Tries To Sort It Out

Finding little to go on, Massimo Pigliucci suggests relying on popular skeptic sites and, er, … himself
Speaking of Skeptical Inquirers, perhaps we should be much more skeptical of the very concept of pseudoscience, at least as it plays out. Read More ›
red-blue-atom-model-over-blurred-blue-and-red-stockpack-adobe-stock
Red blue atom model over blurred blue and red

Bill Dembski: Einstein’s Advice to Bright Young University Grads

His advice, bellowed in parting, may seem obvious but it is challenging in a world that often protects sacred cows over evidence
Sacred cows inhibit thinking because they have no straightforward relationship with the discipline in which they find pasture. Read More ›
data-analysis-science-and-big-data-with-ai-technology-analyst-or-scientist-uses-a-computer-and-dashboard-for-analysis-of-information-on-complex-data-sets-on-computer-insights-development-engineer-stockpack-adobe-stock
Data analysis science and big data with AI technology. Analyst or Scientist uses a computer and dashboard for analysis of information on complex data sets on computer. Insights development engineer

Can AI Replace Science? Gary Smith and Jeffrey Funk Say No

At Fast Company, they explain some of the real problems with mistaking hype for results
The everyday reality is more like this: AI speeds up many tedious processes but doesn’t replace creative thinking. Read More ›
biology-manual-stockpack-adobe-stock
Biology Manual

Wanted: A Theory of Everything Based Only on Science Findings

The philosopher who expressed that wish is probably still looking… he could not find a naturalist theory that worked that way
When science media sound like naturalist (materialist) sermons, that’s what they are. And that is a philosophical choice, not a necessity. Read More ›
thoughtful-man-sitting-down-stockpack-adobe-stock
Thoughtful man sitting down.

Roger Scruton on AI and the Human Soul

Is something missing in the discussion on AI and human exceptionalism? Back in the 1980s, Roger Scruton thought so
Will we start to regard each other as little more than complicated data centers if we lose the concept of the soul entirely? Read More ›