Mind Matters Natural and Artificial Intelligence News and Analysis

Denyse O'Leary

a-depiction-of-electrons-orbiting-an-atomic-nucleus-illustrating-the-fundamental-concept-of-quantum-mechanics-generative-ai-stockpack-adobe-stock
A depiction of electrons orbiting an atomic nucleus, illustrating the fundamental concept of quantum mechanics. Generative Ai.

Our Universe Works, Yet Doesn’t Make Sense … And So?

How can so much uncertainty lie placidly at the basis of our universe but disrupt nothing in particular? We even build better computers because of it
The most reasonable theory of how the universe can be both uncertain at its base and yet reliable in everyday life is the least popular one: deism or theism. Read More ›
hacker-cat-working-job-profession-illustration-generative-ai-stockpack-adobe-stock
hacker cat working job profession illustration generative ai

Generative AI Is Creating a Copyright Crisis for Artists

How does an artist assert copyright when her image was only one of many used to create a new image? How does she make a living if she can’t?
AI companies could be required to record images’ origin and compensate copyright holders. But as Robert J. Marks notes, end users might then have to pay. Read More ›
science-teamwork-and-scientist-with-tablet-in-laboratory-for-communication-pharmaceutical-review-or-planning-employees-collaboration-and-technology-for-research-discussion-and-digital-analysis-stockpack-adobe-stock
Science, teamwork and scientist with tablet in laboratory for communication, pharmaceutical review or planning. Employees, collaboration and technology for research, discussion and digital analysis

It’s Not “Myths” That Cause Distrust in Science But Sad Truths

An astrophysicist, hoping to shore up public trust, means well but gets the problems all wrong
Ethan Siegel offers a fantasy representation of the science world. It may comfort him but it might provoke knowledgeable people to trust science even less. Read More ›
united-by-laughter-kids-of-all-races-come-together-as-best-friends-sharing-pure-joy-and-innocence-embracing-diversity-their-smiles-light-up-the-world-generative-ai-stockpack-adobe-stock
United by laughter, kids of all races come together as best friends, sharing pure joy and innocence. Embracing diversity, their smiles light up the world. Generative AI

An “Evolutionary” Analysis of Childhood Provides No New Knowledge

Archeologist Brenna Hassett offers to explain the evolution of childhood and grandmothers — but, unfortunately, ends up providing no real insight
Humans have reason and ethics and other animals don’t, and there is no evidence that these qualities — that shape our societies — simply “evolved.” Read More ›
a-choice-of-two-ways-woman-at-a-crossroads-stockpack-adobe-stock
A choice of two ways. Woman at a crossroads.

Free Will: Never Let Mere Atoms Near a Keyboard

No free will — and therefore no responsibility — may sound more “cool” than free will but we had better be careful about what we admire
If there is no free will, you can’t say “I didn’t do it” if sociologically, you have a higher probability of doing it than someone else might. Read More ›
beautiful-mystical-forest-in-blue-fog-in-autumn-colorful-landscape-with-enchanted-trees-with-orange-and-red-leaves-scenery-with-path-in-dreamy-foggy-forest-fall-colors-in-october-nature-background-stockpack-adobe-stock
Beautiful mystical forest in blue fog in autumn. Colorful landscape with enchanted trees with orange and red leaves. Scenery with path in dreamy foggy forest. Fall colors in october. Nature background

Can Mathematics Describe Our Innermost Life When Words Fail?

What if the researchers end up with a number that means nothing while the experience itself remains a barely describable personal event?
“Evolution” theories about the human mind play a key role in the manufacture of non-knowledge posing as knowledge, and we are urged to treat them as knowledge. Read More ›
red-deer-stag-in-forest-stockpack-adobe-stock
Red deer stag in forest

Animals Using Healing Plants Is Old News, Says Classics Prof

Adrienne Mayor tells us that ancient and Indigenous peoples learned herbal medicine in part by observing animals
No one knows how animal knowledge of this sort is transmitted. Genetics? Environment? Design in nature? It’s not new and it is still a mystery. Read More ›
a-wildlife-conservationist-caring-for-a-rescued-endangered-species-showing-their-dedication-to-preserving-nature-stockpack-adobe-stock
A wildlife conservationist caring for a rescued, endangered species, showing their dedication to preserving nature.

If Humans Were Just Animals, We Would Not Help Animals

Whether we like it or not, the gulf fixed between humans and other animals is what makes it possible for us to reject cruelty to animals
The “human evolution” narrative that ignores the critical distinction handicaps the thinking of philosopher Hugh Desmond and many others. Read More ›
female-empowerment-in-science-arabic-woman-scientist-with-a-veil-working-with-a-microscope-in-a-high-tech-laboratory-stockpack-adobe-stock
Female empowerment in science: Arabic woman scientist with a veil working with a microscope in a high-tech laboratory

Religious Scientists Balance Work and Faith — on a Knife Edge

A recent article in Nature both sums up — and typifies — the problems they face, weaving around the presumption of atheism
What benefits does the presumption of atheism provide? So many disciplines reel under peer review scandals while trust in science has diminished over the years. Read More ›
stars-nebula-in-space-elements-of-this-image-furnished-by-nasa-stockpack-adobe-stock
Stars nebula in space. Elements of this image furnished by NASA

The Conviction That ET Is Out There Survives Every Setback

Because it is only natural to resist the idea that we are alone, the hope of finding extraterrestrials twists science thinking in strange ways
It’s telling that the obvious evidence for the fine-tuning of the universe, implying design, is — in sharp contrast — evaluated in a hypercritical way. Read More ›
portrait-of-neanderthal-man-tending-to-a-fire-in-a-primitive-shelter-embodying-protection-and-provider-instincts-stockpack-adobe-stock
Portrait of Neanderthal man tending to a fire in a primitive shelter, embodying protection and provider instincts.

Could Neanderthals Speak? It Depends on Who You Talk To

Theorists who will, sadly, never converse with a living Neanderthal imagine things they could and couldn’t do linguistically
Humans can tolerate mysteries quite well as long as we can fill them in with speculations, which in the end tell us mostly about ourselves. Read More ›
medical-illustration-of-monkeypox-virus-3d-illustration-stockpack-adobe-stock
Medical illustration of Monkeypox virus - 3D illustration

Can Viruses Cheat? Cooperate? That’s What Sociovirologists Claim

What does it mean to say that a defective string of genes’s behavior could be self-defeating? Or self-preserving? Where did the “self” come in?
Perhaps sociovirology is an instance of the slow creep of panpsychism in the sciences. But it is early days yet to be sure. Read More ›
man-standing-in-front-of-various-paths-needing-to-make-a-decision-to-move-forward-in-life-generative-ai-stockpack-adobe-stock
man standing in front of various paths, needing to make a decision to move forward in life. Generative Ai.

At Scientific American, free will seems very much alive

The concept is incompatible with their “mind is just the brain” thesis but they can’t let go of it anyway
The debate will surely continue but it’s remarkable that it’s even HELD at Scientific American. Wasn’t materialism supposed to have disproved free will by now? Read More ›
create-yourself-concept-good-looking-young-man-drawing-a-picture-sketch-of-himself-stockpack-adobe-stock
Create yourself concept. Good looking young man drawing a picture, sketch of himself

Neuroscientist: The “I” of Consciousness Cannot Be Explained Away

Skeptical philosopher David Hume tried it and, Raymond Tallis says, things collapsed almost immediately
To suppose that unthinking processes can somehow produce a thinking entity as an illusion is a sheer act of faith — faith in materialism but faith nonetheless. Read More ›
close-up-live-big-lobster-underwater-on-a-on-a-sandy-beach-poster-stockpack-adobe-stock
Close-up live big lobster underwater on a on a sandy beach, poster

What Does It Mean To Say That “Lobsters Are Conscious”?

The New York Declaration on Animal Consciousness, signed in April by 40 researchers, posits a “realistic possibility of conscious experience” in all vertebrates and many invertebrates
Given that human consciousness is a Hard Problem in philosophy, we can expect useful discussions to follow — but also a good deal of silliness. Read More ›
red-pill-blue-pill-concept-the-right-choice-the-concept-of-the-movie-matrix-the-choice-of-tablets-stockpack-adobe-stock
Red Pill Blue Pill concept. The right choice the concept of the movie matrix. The choice of tablets

What Drives the Belief That We Live in a Computer Sim Universe?

The lack of evidence for the sim is admitted — but then we are challenged to prove that it ISN’T true…
If we grasp the psychological role that the belief that we live in a sim universe plays, it’s easier to see why it persists in the absence of evidence. Read More ›
two-tyrannosaurus-rex-are-fighting-in-pine-forest-created-by-generative-ai-stockpack-adobe-stock
Two tyrannosaurus rex are fighting in pine forest . Created by generative AI .

The wildly varying intelligence of big, bad, extinct T. Rex

After centuries with the “stupid” label, T. rex was found in one 2023 study to be as smart as a primate. But then…
A 2024 study suggests that T. rex was only as smart as a crocodile, not a chimp. That might seems like a comedown — except that crocs are fairly sharp. Read More ›
surreal-portrait-of-natures-essence-womans-face-blending-with-lush-trees-and-life-symbolizing-environmental-connection-and-growth-stockpack-adobe-stock
surreal portrait of nature's essence. woman's face blending with lush trees and life, symbolizing environmental connection and growth

Panpsychism Going Mainstream in Popular Media?

Significantly, Hawkins does not try to privilege conventional “consciousness is an illusion” over panpsychism (“everything is conscious”). He treats the two views equally
Panpsychism is very much a materialist theory. It avoids absurdity by admitting that human consciousness is real — but then tries to make it part of nature. Read More ›
earth on precipice
北アメリカを中心としたクリスタルの地球儀の背景に清流が流れている

Gaia Reborn? New Climate Book Sees Earth as Living Entity

The Gaia hypothesis, pioneered by Lynn Margulis and James Lovelock was once ridiculed but Ferris Jabr thinks we should take it seriously to fight climate change
This idea, which can be placed along the panpsychism spectrum, risks making climate issues a religion and will cast specifically human rights into doubt. Read More ›
blue-abstract-lightning-stockpack-adobe-stock
Blue abstract lightning

Astrophysicist: Electricity Can Account For Human Consciousness

Ethan Siegel set out to show that there is no design in the universe and that included reducing consciousness to electricity, with the details still to be ironed out
It’s useful to know that this sort of fact-free performance is acceptable, given the state of a materialist interpretation of consciousness today. Read More ›