Science, God, and Truth: Michael Shermer and Michael Egnor
Watch Episode
Before we get to today’s episode, a quick reminder: In the past, we’ve released interviews in segments over multiple episodes, but we’ve found that this can fragment attention. Now, Mind Matters News releases two full-length interview episodes each month that will be longer, more comprehensive, and we hope, more engaging. These episodes will post on the first Wednesday and the third Friday of each month. The first Wednesday episodes will also be made available in video form on the Bradley Center YouTube channel for those who would prefer to watch it. We hope this new format makes the podcast more enjoyable and more accessible to you!
On this episode of the Mind Matters News podcast, host and neurosurgeon Dr. Michael Egnor welcomes Michael Shermer, historian of science and founder of Skeptic magazine, to discuss Shermer’s new book Truth: What It Is, How to Find It, and Why It Still Matters. Shermer describes his book as the culmination of over three decades of skeptical inquiry. He emphasizes a commitment to a philosophical approach known as fallibilism—the idea that beliefs should be held with varying degrees of probability based on evidence. Shermer suggests that the universe may be uncaused or explained through concepts like the multiverse. He cautions against what he calls “God of the gaps” reasoning, particularly regarding the origins of the genetic code. Just because science has not yet fully explained a phenomenon, says Shermer, does not mean it requires a supernatural explanation.
Dr. Egnor offers a philosophical and theological counterpoint to Shermer’s skepticism. He argues that moral law and natural laws are discoveries that suggest a transcendent mind. Egnor also holds that the intricate mathematical laws of physics that govern the universe are evidence of a mind. Egnor challenges materialist and Darwinian explanations for complex biological information. He shows that Darwinian proposals suffer from circular reasoning and a lack of empirical evidence. He views materialism, atheism, and Darwinism as outdated and spent explanatory forces and questions their ability to fill scientific gaps in our understanding. God’s existence, argues Egnor, should be treated as a straightforward scientific theory derived through reason, an inference he says we can draw based on the evidence of nature’s regularity and complexity.
Additional Resources
- Both of these men argue their cases in recent books: Shermer’s Truth and Egnor’s The Immortal Mind.
- More with Dr. Egnor:
