Mind Matters Natural and Artificial Intelligence News and Analysis

CategoryArtificial general intelligence (AGI)

woman-teaching-art-to-a-robot-stockpack-adobe-stock-610935551-stockpack-adobestock
Woman teaching art to a robot

McDiarmid: The Critical Flaw in Thinking AI Can Do Just Anything

At the Chicago Tribune, he asks readers to recognize what is missing from the mix
Russian philosopher Nikolai Berdyaev long ago argued that human creativity springs from freedom — just what machines do not have. Read More ›
book-of-the-universe-opened-magic-book-with-planets-and-galaxies-elements-of-this-image-furnished-by-nasa-stockpack-adobe-stock
Book of the universe - opened magic book with planets and galaxies. Elements of this image furnished by NASA

Absolutist, Prohibitionist, and Luddite? Oh, My!

Pushing back against labels that shut down the conversation
Because he says the “genie” (or maybe the GenAI) “is out of the bottle,” Dr. Dembski wants me to submit to the myth of progress by sharing even one use of AI in education that I support. Read More ›
cybernetic-dj-sets-the-beat-a-futuristic-cyborg-dj-in-a-vibr-1351415158-stockpack-adobestock
Cybernetic DJ Sets the Beat: A futuristic cyborg DJ in a vibrant club, surrounded by neon lights, hypes up the crowd.

Why the Real Danger of AI Is Not What You Think

What really makes Donald Wunsch stand out is his focus on what AI can actually do today
His paper, “Artificial General Intelligence Is Nowhere Near, Artificial Specific Stupidity Is Already Here,” challenges both hype and groundless fear. Read More ›
programmer-working-on-their-professional-development-types-on-a-laptop-computer-keyboard-coding-language-user-interface-on-screens-development-of-software-and-coding-chatgpt-ai-and-webdesign-stockpack-adobe-stock
Programmer working on their professional development types on a laptop computer keyboard. Coding Language User Interface on Screens. Development of software and coding, ChatGPT AI and webdesign

Why I Respectfully Disagree With Bill Dembski on AI in Education

Are GenAI chatbots really the bridge over the gulf of our education crisis?
Dr. Dembski wants us to use technology with wisdom. I share his broader goal, but not the use of generative AI chatbots to get there. Read More ›
llm-ai-large-language-model-concept-businessman-use-tablet-a-886081817-stockpack-adobe_stock
LLM, AI Large Language Model concept. Businessman use tablet and laptop with LLM icons. A language model distinguished by its general-purpose language generation capability. Chat AI.

The Chatbots’ Most Dangerous Correlations

To give these machines blind trust really is the case of the blind leading the blind, and that is not likely to end well
When you prompt an LLM, the entire conversation acts as a prompt driving the reply. Thus your prompt can push the LLM in unforeseen, unintended directions. Read More ›
businessman-use-artificial-intelligence-ai-technology-for-en-1581362027-stockpack-adobestock
Businessman use artificial intelligence AI technology for enhanced work efficiency data analysis and efficient tools, Unlocking work potential with AI solutions chatbot help solve work problems.

Straight Talk About AI From a Valley Tech Exec

Microsoft vice-president Uli Homann lays out what it can — and can’t — really do for you
In Homann’s view, AI is best seen as “autocomplete with ambition.” But that doesn’t mean it can’t be quite useful. Read More ›
chat-gpt-artificial-intelligence-copy-writing-bot-by-open-ai-611480062-stockpack-adobestock
Chat GPT Artificial Intelligence copy writing bot by Open AI. Robot for student homework, education.

Large Language Models: Inconsistent Because They’re Unintelligent

Here’s what happened when I tested popular LLMs on student exercise questions I have been using for over fifty years
Claims that an LLM is intelligent don’t square with the fact that it may answer a question one way and, a few seconds later, simply contradict itself. Read More ›
aidriven-chatbots-assisting-customer-service-automated-commu-873108619-stockpack-adobestock
AIdriven chatbots assisting customer service, automated communication, concept

Will Reliance on AI Mean a Vast Drop in New Knowledge Production?

Dependence on AI assistants, for example, was found to greatly reduce discussion among peers, where new ideas are offered and evaluated
Ultimately, the AI knowledge system will be enriched or impoverished by human decisions, not by discovering a superintelligence. Read More ›
facial-recognition-technology-to-monitor-the-population-on-b-608983195-stockpack-adobestock
Facial recognition technology to monitor the population on busy street. Generative AI

The Real Threat AI Poses to Us Is Created by Widespread Abuse

In If Anyone Builds It, Yudkowsky and Soares are not really grappling with this problem
The authors really believe in AI doom. Soares has stopped contributing to a retirement plan. I show that the serious problem is NOT superintelligence. Read More ›
core-of-the-machine-3d-illustration-of-complex-futuristic-sc-259694908-stockpack-adobestock
Core of the machine / 3D illustration of complex futuristic science fiction brain nucleus machinery background

Can an AI Really Develop a Mind of Its Own?

Specifically, can an AI develop a mind with its own goals and desires, capable of plans and strategies — as the authors of If Anyone Builds It believe?
Even if we adopt a materialist view of the mind, I believe I can show why it is not possible for a machine to develop a mind. Read More ›
neural-network-of-a-dog-brain-with-big-data-and-artificial-i-557194197-stockpack-adobestock
Neural network of a dog brain with big data and artificial intelligence circuit board in the head of a blue canine, outlining concepts of a digital brain, computer Generative AI stock illustration

Fearing the Terminator: Does Current Tech Warrant the Doomsaying?

People will worry less if they understand why the text generation programs not only do not think but in fact cannot think
Bottom line: Text generative AIs do not capture meaning. They capture relationships which approximate meaning well enough to be useful. Read More ›
cybersecurity-big-data-robots-ai-innovation-idea-stockpack-a-177101726-stockpack-adobestock
Cybersecurity big data, robots ai innovation idea

Fearing the Terminator, Missing the Obvious

In Part 1 of my review of the new AI Doom book, If Anyone Builds It, Everyone Dies, we look at how the authors first developed the underlying idea
By 2020, authors Yudlowsky and Soares were already Doomers but the rapid success of ChatGPT and similar models heightened their worries. Read More ›
education-laptop-student-teenager-studying-boy-learning-home-656956968-stockpack-adobestock
education laptop student teenager studying boy learning homework idea thinking dreaming student thoughtful looking education inspiration study young school

Natural Intelligence Creates Information; AI Processes It

Human intelligence creates new information through free, purposeful choices, while AI can only process/transform existing data according to predetermined rules
If intelligence essentially involves agency, artificial general intelligence (AGI) in the human sense is not attainable by computation alone. Read More ›
clarifying-complex-ideas-theme-with-light-bulb-flat-lay-stoc-619300211-stockpack-adobestock
Clarifying complex ideas theme with light bulb - Flat lay

Podcast: The Challenge of Proving Creativity in AI

AI researcher Mappouras discusses the limitations of the Lovelace test for AI creativity with host Robert Marks
Mappouras doesn’t rule out creativity in machines; he wants to develop a test that could recognize it. Read More ›
data-driven-ai-and-analytics-concept-with-neural-networks-ma-1063111999-stockpack-adobestock
Data-driven AI and analytics concept with neural networks, machine learning, and big data stream. Illustrate data flow technology and science for predictive systems, ideal for innovation and business.

Intelligence Demands More than Pressing a Lever to Obtain Water

I continue to be astonished by how willing people are to assume that LLMs are intelligent because they give glib, confident answers
Human trainers can nudge LLMs to give good answers for specific questions but this training doesn’t prepare them for subtle variations. Read More ›
conceptual-art-of-think-brain-mind-mental-health-spiritual-soul-and-psychology-concept-idea-art-surreal-drawing-illustration-isolated-on-a-white-background-stockpack-adobe-stock
Conceptual art of think, brain mind, mental health, spiritual, soul and psychology. concept idea art. surreal drawing illustration. isolated on a white background.

COSM 2025 Panel to Tackle the Hard Problem: Consciousness

Michael Egnor sees the failure to find a “material center of consciousness” in the brain as a science success, not failure. It points to an important truth about us
As prominent neuroscientist Christof Koch’s recent difficulties with Cancel Culture show, the cracks in materialist neuroscience are getting harder to paper over. Read More ›
a-humanoid-robot-philosopher-contemplating-the-nature-of-con-1228267447-stockpack-adobestock
A humanoid robot philosopher contemplating the nature of consciousness in a virtual reality chamber, abstract digital environment with neural networks and philosophical texts, Innovative style

Brain Surgeon Shows Why AI Can Never Become Human

Spoiler alert: AI requires physical hardware; the mind does not
AI can never be more than a machine; the human mind soars far above any machine model. Be nice to your robot. But don’t think she is human. Read More ›
great-idea-concept-stockpack-adobe-stock-91781543-stockpack-adobestock
great idea concept

Podcast: A New Test to Measure Understanding in AI Models

The Turing Test 2.0 is based on the view that intelligence is the ability to extract new knowledge from existing information and apply it consistently across time and context
The Turing Test 2.0 mirrors the way good teachers test students — not asking for memorized answers but for concepts to be applied in unfamiliar situations. Read More ›
bearded-businessman-in-a-suit-looking-surprised-stockpack-ad-533879193-stockpack-adobestock
Bearded businessman in a suit looking surprised

A Realistic Direction for Artificial General Intelligence Today

Based on GPT5's performance to date, it would make a superb substitute for a mansplainer I know of — call him Brock
The fundamental problem remains; models like GPT-5 are hobbled by their inherent inability to relate the text they input and output to the real world. Read More ›
futuristic-and-conceptual-image-representing-smart-integrati-720201229-stockpack-adobestock
Futuristic and conceptual image representing smart integration, featuring the letters 'AI' stylized in a high-tech font, surrounded by intricate circuit connections, advanced artificial intelligence

Measuring Machine Intelligence Using Turing Test 2.0

Podcast: Georgios Mappouras’s updated approach asks whether machines can go beyond imitation to produce new knowledge
Mappouras’s General Intelligence Threshold offers a test question: Can the system generate insights that were not directly programmed into it? Read More ›