Mind Matters Natural and Artificial Intelligence News and Analysis

Gary Varner

desolate-alien-planet-landscape-with-volcanic-eruption-and-stormy-sky-stockpack-adobe-stock
Desolate alien planet landscape with volcanic eruption and stormy sky

Alien: Covenant (2017): When the Prophet Fails

Everybody trudges onto the planet in what amounts to hunting gear and they begin looking for Shaw’s ship...
What’s the point of Daniels being the screenwriters' prophet if the character isn’t going to even try to take any sort of action to prevent a disaster? Read More ›
vibrant-blue-digital-signals-pulse-and-swirl-in-a-mesmerizing-dance-against-a-dark-mysterious-background-evoking-cutting-edge-technology-and-data-transmission-stockpack-adobe-stock
Vibrant blue digital signals pulse and swirl in a mesmerizing dance against a dark, mysterious background, evoking cutting-edge technology and data transmission.

Alien: Covenant (2017): A Story Driven by Stupidity, Coincidence

Nothing seems to happen as the natural result of a character’s choices, consistent with personality and motive
It’s exciting but the audience will likely notice the hands of the writers moving the pieces where they want them to go. Read More ›
an-expedition-to-the-outer-reaches-of-the-galaxy-where-the-void-of-space-gives-way-to-the-beauty-of-distant-nebulae-and-star-clusters-concept-of-cosmic-journey-generative-ai-stockpack-adobe-stock
An expedition to the outer reaches of the galaxy, where the void of space gives way to the beauty of distant nebulae and star clusters. Concept of cosmic journey. Generative Ai.

Prometheus (2012): In the End Did Dr. Shaw Really Learn Anything?

Elizabeth Shaw’s faith has been challenged throughout the film; for example, she learns that aliens, not God, created humanity. But do her responses make sense?
While it’s good that Dr. Shaw manages to maintain her faith throughout her various trials, it's unclear why she continues the quest all alone. Read More ›
view-of-the-earth-on-fire-from-space-flames-wrap-around-the-blue-planet-searing-heat-engulfs-the-world-stockpack-adobe-stock
View of the Earth on fire from space, flames wrap around the blue planet, searing heat engulfs the world

Prometheus (2012): Oops. Our Alien Creators Now Want to Kill Us

What should have been an awful revelation degenerates into what seems like the dumbest scene ever filmed
It’s not even clear how the crew knows that the alien creator wants to destroy humanity, let alone why. Read More ›
photo-of-moon-surface-stockpack-unsplash
photo of moon surface

Prometheus (2012): Don’t Touch the Aliens’ Stuff!

Upon entering what is described as the Engineers’ “temple,” the crew unleashes strange and deadly perils…
After contact with deadly alien chemicals, Dr. Shaw finds herself pregnant with an alien life form and, worse, Fifield returns as a zombie. Read More ›
alien-planet-landscape-beautiful-forest-the-surface-of-an-exoplanet-stockpack-adobe-stock
alien planet landscape, beautiful forest the surface of an exoplanet

Sci-fi Film Explores Idea That Earth’s Life Was Seeded From Space

Prometheus 2012 offers an intriguing premise: ancient civilizations were told in mysterious ways of a habitable moon in a distant galaxy (Part 1 of 4)
The corporation funding the mission to investigate the moon in Prometheus (2012) may have a different agenda from what the crew supposes. Read More ›
portal-in-the-universe-with-a-fiery-glow-around-contours-of-dark-trees-stockpack-adobe-stock
Portal in the Universe with a fiery glow around. Contours of dark trees

Interstellar 2014, Part 5: Time Travel Saves — But Also Destroys

Time travel solves some problems for planet Earth but it turns out to be no match for human mortality and sundered relationships
While the film begins well, it eventually falls into the trap of spectacle over substance. But I recommend it for the music, the acting, and the visuals. Read More ›
abstract-innovation-space-travel-successful-business-future-disruption-strategy-for-time-and-space-travel-portal-gateway-3d-rendering-stockpack-adobe-stock
Abstract innovation space travel successful business. Future disruption strategy for time and space travel portal gateway. 3d rendering.

Interstellar (2014), Review Part 4: So Who Are “They” Anyway?

Will we at last find out?
Cooper says that the mysterious "They" have “evolved.” How in the world did natural selection select the fifth dimension? Read More ›
scene-of-an-astronaut-standing-on-an-unknown-icy-planet-with-a-breathtaking-landscape-stockpack-adobe-stock
scene of an astronaut standing on an unknown icy planet with a breathtaking landscape.

Interstellar (2014): Dr Mann Uses Nature to Justify Murder

The awful secret that comes to light while the crew visits Dr. Mann's planet has nothing to do with the planet

Last Saturday, we looked at Cooper and his crew landing on the first of three planets that might sustain human life. Humanity’s time on Earth is running out, and Cooper’s crew has been tasked with finding it a new home. The first planet they tried turned out not to be so ideal, and that one trip cost them decades of valuable time thanks to relativity. The planet was too close to a black hole, which meant that it had created a dramatic time shift. On Earth, over twenty years have passed since their mission began. Now the crew is traveling on to the next planet. The extra time spent on the first planet has left them with just enough fuel Read More ›

galaxy and planet
Abstract planets and space background

Interstellar (2014): The Plot Thickens—Well, Relatively…

Aside from adventures and misadventures exploring Miller’s planet, discovery of a dreadful secret awaits the crew
Interstellar succeeds in the difficult task of creating sympathy for an initially unlikeable character via a harrowing plot turn. Read More ›
dust-bowl-stockpack-adobe-stock
dust bowl

Interstellar (2014): Starting Out at the End of the World

As Earth’s surface is turning to dust, a former NASA pilot is offered another mission, to help find a way to transport humanity to a habitable planet
Interstellar’s visuals and music score are excellent but more backstory would have helped orient the reader. We are largely left to guess how disaster occurred. Read More ›
robot-police-officer-patrols-metropolis-using-a-drone-skyscrapers-stockpack-adobe-stock
robot police officer patrols metropolis using a drone, skyscrapers

RoboCop 2014: Murphy Is a Real Boy After All

After his wife confronts him with troubling news about his son, Murphy starts a chain of events that enables him to confront key sources of crime and corruption
The political commentary is on the nose but lazy writing took much of the punch out of the ending. Still it may be worth your time. Read More ›
big-robot-and-soldiers-in-a-fight-stockpack-adobe-stock
big robot and soldiers in a fight

Does a Lack of Empathy Make You More Efficient?

Robocop (2014) tests out that thesis when Murphy, now a robocop, is matched against actual robots
With all of the city’s criminal records downloaded into his mind and his dopamine levels nearly zero, Murphy meets the press… Read More ›
asian-cyberpunk-robot-police-officer-accompanied-by-a-robotic-dog-neon-lights-chinatown-stockpack-adobe-stock
Asian cyberpunk robot police officer accompanied by a robotic dog, neon lights, Chinatown

Robocop 2014: A Good Movie Hampered by Bad Timing

The 2014 remake of RoboCop is considered a failure by most. I disagree. It has its problems but it is pretty solid in many respects
The film implies the existence of the human soul, as that seems to be pretty much all that Alex Murphy has left as he begins a new life as a robocop. Read More ›
man-vs-ai-concept-created-with-generative-ai-technology-stockpack-adobe-stock
Man vs AI concept created with Generative AI technology

I, Robot Review, Part 3: Why Must Robots Always Enslave Us?

Even after watching the movie several times when I was younger, I’d still forgotten that Robertson wasn’t the main villain

Last time, Spooner’s investigation into Dr. Lanning’s apparent suicide led him to Sonny, the robot who claimed it could dream. It turns out that Sonny’s dream isn’t a dream at all, but an image programmed by Dr. Lanning. It was meant to lead Spooner to a storage area where all the older robots were being kept. Once Spooner finds the exact spot where he was supposed to be standing in Sonny’s dream, he plays the hologram Dr. Lanning recorded before he died. The hologram program is simple. The doctor recorded certain responses that are triggered by the right questions. Spooner begins talking to the hologram until it tells him what he needs to know. Dr. Lanning’s hologram says there’s going Read More ›

purple-smoke-and-purple-clouds-on-dark-background-stockpack-adobe-stock
purple smoke and purple clouds on dark background

Spaceman Review, Part 3: Inside the Chopra Cloud at Last

There has to be a gem inside this film somewhere because, despite all the problems, I still found myself rooting for Jakub and Lenka
In the end, I wanted Jakub and Lenka to restore their relationship. So, if you have a couple hours, give Spaceman a try. You just might find that gem. Read More ›
robot-android-men-running-stockpack-adobe-stock
robot android men running

I, Robot Review, Part 2: The Ghosts in the Machine

Dr. Lanning describes these ghosts as random segments of code and asks questions like why robots choose to stand together rather than alone when they’re stored in a dark place
Dr. Calvin has been put in charge of decommissioning Sonny, but she’s found some unsettling things about the robot. For one thing, it can break The Three Laws. Read More ›
abstract-flight-in-retro-neon-hyper-warp-space-in-the-tunnel-3d-illustration-stockpack-adobe-stock
Abstract flight in retro neon hyper warp space in the tunnel 3d illustration

Spaceman Review, Part 3

Sometimes you have to leave what you love to go on a mission

Last time, we talked about Jakub’s new buddy, a giant spider that may or may not be real. This potential hallucination wants to help the astronaut with his loneliness because his wife, Lenka, has left him. The trouble is that the spider’s idea of helping poor Jakub is forcing him to remember his past. The writer wanted to give Jakub a redemption arch using these flashbacks; however, the astronaut’s memories were shown in a disjointed order, confusing the story and making Lenka look very bad, which made her and Jakub’s relationship difficult to root for. The chaotic flashbacks, mixed with a variety of plot holes, made for a very irritating story. One of the most glaring plot holes arises when Read More ›

space-stockpack-adobe-stock
space

Spaceman: Along Came a Spider and Sat Down… Well, Maybe

The spider is an alien with a somewhat complex relationship to people and toilets
Adam Sandler gives a marvelous performance at a key point, but the script doesn’t give a specific moment that tells the audience what changed his mind. Read More ›