Mind Matters Natural and Artificial Intelligence News and Analysis
glowing-blue-large-question-mark-digital-network-design-abst-1314641083-stockpack-adobestock
Glowing blue large question mark, digital network design, abstract concept, symbolizes inquiry, problem-solving, technology, innovation, digital future
Image Credit: PhotoArtHub - Adobe Stock

Star Wars: The Last Jedi Review Part 2

The question wasn’t answered until I later saw Rey still offering Luke his lightsaber, but by that time, I had even more questions
Share
Facebook
Twitter/X
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

The Title Crawl Once Again Confuses Things

Right from the beginning, the film creates more questions than answers. The first words the audience sees after the title are “The First Order reigns.” Why? Just because the First Order destroyed the Republic doesn’t mean they’ve established their rule. Snoke hasn’t given any speeches or declarations as far as we know.

What if there is an Empire remnant that would like to take control, or a gang, or any other number of groups? Plus, the First Order has just lost its Starkiller base. Strictly speaking, it’s more vulnerable now than ever, and the First Order has killed billions of people.

Everyone should be rallying against them to take them out before they can gather even more power. And how have they managed to secure a powerful position in the galaxy when they’ve barely had time to reassemble their armies after such a colossal defeat?

The audience is basically expected to believe that the First Order is now in charge just because they’ve destroyed the main body of the government. However, the prior movie seemed to suggest that while the First Order was a large faction, it had yet to secure any authority in the galaxy.

They are supposed to ignore that republics have multiple centers of power. They are supposed to ignore that the First Order was just defeated in the previous film. The consequences of The Force Awakens are meant to be ignored entirely.

The board is now completely reset, and the audience is just meant to accept that. Already, one can sense the numerous problems, and the movie isn’t even past the first line.

Apparently, now Snoke is unleashing his merciless legions that for some reason weren’t on the planet-sized base. Then the title crawl mentions that Leia and the Resistance stand alone against the First Order, but of course, as was discussed during the reviews of The Force Awakens, there’s really no reason for this. After that, it mentions that the Resistance hopes that somehow Luke will be able to “restore hope” when he returns. The problem with this is that we don’t even know what Luke knows about The First Order at this point.

We have no idea if he was involved with the war against the First Order in the beginning, whether his disappearance was what helped establish The First Order, whether he would’ve left at all if he’d known about the First Order, nothing. The only real clue to this question the trilogy provides is that Luke and Leia knew who Snoke was, and Leia blamed Snoke for Kylo’s turn. That’s it.

Finally, the title crawl mentions that the Resistance has been spotted, which we knew anyway, and only serves to remind the audience that the Resistance has yet to evacuate when they clearly should’ve. This is a plot hole. There’s no way around it.

The Last Jedi has taken an unanswered issue from the first movie and now confirmed that the Resistance has done something that no army in its right mind would do: stay put and wait around to see if the battle was won or lost before leaving. Don’t forget a very important detail that distinguishes Starkiller base from the first Death Star.

In A New Hope, the Death Star was closing in. It’s arguable that if the Rebels had tried to flee, the Empire might’ve tried to run them down. But Starkiller base is somewhere else in the galaxy. It’s a super long-range weapon, so the First Order is nowhere near the Resistance.

There’s no reason why the Resistance wouldn’t begin an evacuation the second they knew the First Order had located them. But then, even after refusing to leave during the battle, they continue to wait for no apparent reason, then randomly decide to leave hours if not days later.

The Force Awaken should’ve shown transport ships trying to flee the base even before the Resistance knew the outcome of the film’s final battle. Why take chances?

And Rian Johnson could’ve dodged this issue by simply having some time pass. Sure, failing to flee is ridiculous, but if Rian Johnson had just put in a time lapse, then the plot hole becomes inconsequential to his story and is therefore less distracting, but now, that plot hole from the first movie has a giant spotlight placed on it because it looks like the Resistance is about to be wiped out thanks to its own incompetence, and this issue in the previous film is going to be the inciting incident for the next movie.

So, why didn’t he just place everyone in new camps? This would’ve made the most sense, which is probably why a far superior film titled The Empire Strikes Back had the Rebels on Hoth and the Empire struggling to find them in their star destroyers. Well, it seems that Rian had a very specific thing in mind for Luke, a subversion/destruction of our understanding of the series’s main character.

The title crawl is three paragraphs long, and, although it has a lot of words, it explains very little, and the exposition it provides doesn’t make any sense. I’m harping on this because I’d forgotten how monumentally boring this movie was.

The Force Awakens was bad, but it was also mostly entertaining. It moved fast, and the beginning was so strong that I was able to follow along, even when things didn’t make sense later. But The Last Jedi is instantly confusing.

The Force Awakens’ title crawl was confusing as well, but in a different way. The Force Awakens shook up the worldbuilding to return the characters back to their positions in A New Hope. This was a cheap move, but at least it was clear.

I understood what was about to happen, mostly because I’d already seen A New Hope. But The Last Jedi’s title crawl is confusing not when it comes to the worldbuilding but in terms of the setup.

To put it simply, I had no idea how or where the characters were, what they were doing, or why they were doing it by the end of the exposition, and if a writer is unable to clarify such things by the end of a block of text devoted solely to an info dump, well, that writer is already in a lot of trouble.

And because the movie is confusing right from the beginning, I felt particularly bored throughout the whole film simply because I couldn’t follow anything until I’d watched it multiple times.

So, let’s look at the opening scene. One of the Resistance fighters is yelling at another Resistance fighter, and it’s clear that they are evacuating the base from the previous film.

Already, I’m thinking, “Wait? They’re still there?” Why? There seems to be a sense of urgency with the Resistance, but why is there this sense of urgency now? There was no sense of urgency when Rey left to find Luke. What happened?

The audience never receives an explanation because the First Order is quickly seen in the sky. They arrived before the Resistance could finish their evacuation. But again, why did the Resistance wait so long? Why didn’t they at least leave at the same time as Rey?

Furthermore, why are they all waiting to leave at once? They didn’t do that in The Empire Strikes Back. In that film, they had an established rendezvous point, and they were leaving in waves as fast as they could, planning to reunite later.

Why is the majority of the fleet in this movie just floating around in space waiting for everyone else? They’re giving the First Order the perfect opportunity to destroy the Resistance in one battle.

The movie soon reveals Hux, and now I’m even more confused. The last time I saw him, he’d run to Snoke, and he was ordered to retrieve Kylo Ren from the planet—I have no idea how Hux was even supposed to find him before the base exploded—then bring him back to Snoke because Snoke wanted to complete Kylo’s training.

So, Hux had to find Kylo, bring him to Snoke, return to his men, who were either scattered or gathering at some rendezvous point, coordinate a counterattack after taking stock of their losses, and then travel to the Resistance base all before the Resistance—who has nothing left to do but leave—can evacuate the planet.

When I first watched the film, I wasn’t sure whether this battle was taking place immediately after the destruction of the Starkiller base or if some time had passed and they’d found a similar-looking planet. That question wasn’t answered until I later saw Rey still offering Luke his lightsaber, but by that time, I had even more questions, and I’ll cover those in the next review.


Gary Varner

Gary Varner is a Science Fiction and Fantasy enthusiast with a bachelor’s degree in Theater Arts, and he spends his time working and raising his daughter who he suspects will one day be president of the United States. For more reviews as well as serial novels, go to www.garypaulvarner.com to read more.
Enjoying our content?
Support the Walter Bradley Center for Natural and Artificial Intelligence and ensure that we can continue to produce high-quality and informative content on the benefits as well as the challenges raised by artificial intelligence (AI) in light of the enduring truth of human exceptionalism.

Star Wars: The Last Jedi Review Part 2