So Was It a Worldwide Hack? Cyberattack? A Number of Experts Weigh In
Read what they say and consider. Note especially the advice on what to do if it happens againMany people are naturally wondering why it all happened all at once: Hackers? Russia? Outdated equipment? Incompetence? All of the above?
At professional networking site LinkedIn, editor Rachel Kleinman offers a rundown of perspectives from tech experts. Here are a few:
● From cybersecurity analyst Nicole Perlroth:
Nobody asked: What if, in the name of progress, we were creating THE RIPEST ATTACK SURFACE IN HUMAN HISTORY?
We are now entirely dependent on systems that almost nobody understands end-to-end, that increasingly few people can triage, and that attackers can now probe at machine speed, just as the cavalry disappears.
We are entering a period of unprecedented technological instability. “Software Beirut” is the apt analogy.
● Susie Cranston, wealth management CEO:
At Cresset, we are having more conversations with clients about how to anticipate, prepare for, and navigate these disruptions. And these conversations go well beyond investments.
Do you manage a company that may suddenly be unable to operate? How would you communicate with employees and customers? What would you do if payment or banking services were unavailable for several days? Is your home prepared? Do your family members know what to do in different scenarios?
● Ethan Mollick, professor at a GenAI lab:
I keep seeing speculation that AI is behind all of the recent system crashes, and it is… but only indirectly. Defensive AI is discovering security vulnerabilities at an unheard-of rate, and if those holes aren’t patched, they may be exploited by other AIs. So now there is reporting that the issue is a rush of patches before the holidays to address security concerns, and the sudden burst of patches is destabilizing to already fragile systems. Makes sense, as CIOs I spoken with have been exhausted trying to keep up with security patch demands & balancing that with normal operations.
● Kelsey Waag, cybersecurity risk advisor, offers five pieces of consumer advice. Here are three:
3 Save PDFs of the things you’d otherwise have to log in to find: the last few bank statements, your insurance card, your lease or mortgage details.
4 Pick one afternoon this month to log out of everything on a spare device and see what you can’t get back into. It tells you more than any checklist.
5 Notice which three websites apps you’d panic without, and ask what you’d do if they were gone for a day. Wondering is most of the exercise.
● Offensive security consultant August Vansickle:
I’m also concerned that there is plenty of motive to not be transparent about AI systems being integrated into production systems, so I’m looking closely for that in these situations, just that a lack of testing and planning could cause different decisions being made by AI and contribute additionally to network outages occurring.
A number of others also offered thoughts.
Kleinman and many of the experts she links to seem especially concerned that we not give in to “social media panic”: She reminds us, “Cybersecurity experts, meanwhile, note AI ‘makes it difficult to discern’ actual threats from the constant patches ‘that amount to their remedy.’”
Well, yes, panic is useless by nature. But that is hardly a new insight. The situation outlined is enough to justify grave concern about what the tech bros are getting us into.
So is it a worldwide hack or cyberattack?
At Wired, Andy Greenberg and Lily Hay Newman report,
The baseline for that fact-finding, as anyone tasked with investigating these incidents will tell you, is that the vast majority of these digital breakdowns are not the result of malicious intent but rather casualties of IT admins’ constant war to keep computer systems from collapsing under the weight of their own complexity.
“I’ve just seen enough times where we thought maybe it’s a cyberattack and it turns out it’s not. Sometimes it will be, but typically not,” says Matthew Prince, CEO of the internet infrastructure company Cloudflare. “Right now, most of what we’re seeing is the standard background noise. Stuff breaks, and that’s just the nature of complex systems.”
“How to Tell If It’s a Cyberattack or Just an Outage,” November 17, 2026
A widely used expression used to be, “Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity” — or incompetence, or just being out of one’s depth.
We can weigh all these factors as we come to know more. The main question now is whether the outages will subside for now, continue or worsen, and what choices we face in each of these scenarios.
