Mind Matters Natural and Artificial Intelligence News and Analysis
San Francisco aerial view from sea side. Port of San Francisco in the front. City downtown and skyscrapers at sunrise.
San Francisco aerial view from sea side. Port of San Francisco in the front. City downtown and skyscrapers at sunrise.
Featured image: San Francisco, snow globe view/dell, Adobe Stock

A Silicon Valley Insider Asks the Awkward Questions

Billionaire venture capitalist Peter Thiel, speaking at COSM in October, has a history of challenging Valley orthodoxies

How would you respond if PayPal co-founder Peter Thiel asked you his favorite interview question: “Tell me something that’s true that almost nobody agrees with you on.”

According to Thiel, this interview question helps pinpoint applicants who are innovative thinkers with an abundance of ideas — the type of person who can survive Silicon Valley’s competitive atmosphere.

The question, according to Thiel, tests both originality and courage. “It’s always socially awkward to tell the interviewer something that the interviewer might not agree with,” the billionaire explains.

Ruth Umoh, “Why PayPal co-founder Peter Thiel swears by this curveball job interview question” at make it/CNBC

Even if no one ever asks, it’s a good mental exercise. Most of us could alter it slightly to “Tell me something that’s true that almost nobody in your group agrees with you on.” Focusing on what makes us unique helps with job searches and assorted other challenges.

Thiel, who will be speaking at the COSM conference in Bellevue, Washington, October 23–25, 2019, isn’t afraid to ruffle much bigger feathers. As a Silicon Valley great, he has been unsparing in his public concern over Google’s cloudy relations with China.

Join George Gilder and some of the world’s leading tech minds in Seattle for COSM Technology Summit October 23-25, Bellevue, Washington! Interact with Peter Thiel, Ken Fisher, Ray Kurzweil, and Babak Parviz (Google Glass inventor) https://cosm.technology/

Earlier this month, as an early investor in Google’s DeepMind (of chess- and gobot fame), he questioned Google’s cozy relations with China. China makes no distinction between military and civilian enterprises and openly seeks total control over citizens’ lives (via an AI-enforced social credit system):

A.I.’s military power is the simple reason that the recent behavior of America’s leading software company, Google — starting an A.I. lab in China while ending an A.I. contract with the Pentagon — is shocking. As President Barack Obama’s defense secretary Ash Carter pointed out last month, “If you’re working in China, you don’t know whether you’re working on a project for the military or not.”

No intensive investigation is required to confirm this. All one need do is glance at the Communist Party of China’s own constitution: Xi Jinping added the principle of “civil-military fusion,” which mandates that all research done in China be shared with the People’s Liberation Army, in 2017.

Peter Thiel, “Good for Google, Bad for America” at New York Times

His question, “How can Google use the rhetoric of ‘borderless’ benefits to justify working with the country whose ‘Great Firewall’ has imposed a border on the internet itself?”, is timely. China’s government uses high tech for, among other things, sophisticated racial profiling.

Elsewhere, he has described Google’s ties with China as “seemingly treasonous” (Bloomberg, July 2019) and calling for an investigation in “a not excessively gentle manner” (Business Insider, July 2019).

Many Google employees appear to share Thiel’s concerns, hence recent reports of internal unrest over dubiously ethical projects. His view is also supported by Richard Clarke, White House cybersecurity chief under former President Obama, who noted that Google no longer has the Pentagon as a client and “If you turn around and you work on artificial intelligence in China, and you don’t really know what they’re going to do with that, I think there’s an issue.(CNBC, July 2019)

Thiel has a unique platform from which to raise these hot-button issues; he is very much a Silicon Valley insider. He has been, for example, chairman and CEO of PayPal and an investor in Facebook (2004) He still sits on Facebook’s board. His venture capital firm, Founders Fund (2005), has invested in Airbnb, Lyft, and Elon Musk’s SpaceX. So most of us have heard of at least one enterprise he had a hand in.

And yet Thiel still makes independent decisions. While at Stanford (BA, Philosophy, 1989), he founded a newspaper that was critical of political correctness. To this day, his Thiel Foundation gives young entrepreneurs $100,000 over two years to just forget university and start their businesses.

He also moved from San Francisco to Los Angeles in early 2018, denouncing Silicon Valley as a “one-party state.” (Humble Google employees have similar stories to tell.)

Meanwhile, he has written The Diversity Myth: Multiculturalism and Political Intolerance on Campus (1995) and Zero to One: Notes on Startups, or How to Build the Future (2014), neither of which would help much if he had hoped to pose as a New Establishment stuffed shirt.

Perhaps the independent decision-making that seems to be part of Thiel’s success helps to explain his challenging interview question. If you can get to COSM this year, be sure to get your seat early for his session. If you can’t make it, at least have fun pondering his question and learning more about your own unique gifts.

The internet doesn’t free anyone by itself. China is testing 100% surveillance on the Uighurs, a strategically critical minority. (Heather Zeiger)

Google is collecting data on schoolkids. Some say that’s okay because the firm supplies a lot of free software and hardware to schools.


Google engineer reveals search engine bias. He found Google pretty neutral in 2014; the bias started with the US 2016 election.

Featured image: San Francisco, snow globe view/dell, Adobe Stock

Mind Matters News

Breaking and noteworthy news from the exciting world of natural and artificial intelligence at MindMatters.ai.

A Silicon Valley Insider Asks the Awkward Questions