Mind Matters Natural and Artificial Intelligence News and Analysis

CategoryArtificial general intelligence (AGI)

wren-bird-closeup-stockpack-adobe-stock-651033338-stockpack-adobestock
Wren Bird Closeup

Part 3: A Wren Arrives — and Ruffles Many a Feather

Dr. Wren, a cognitive scientist, identifies a problem with assuming that adding another ten thousand pigeons to the project will produce novel designs...
We remain confronted by the same old mystery: who, or what, imagines the birdhouse in the first place? Read More ›
a-mesmerizing-illustration-of-mathematics-featuring-a-vibran-1278627221-stockpack-adobestock
A mesmerizing illustration of mathematics featuring a vibrant swirling vortex of numbers symbols and geometric shapes in shades of electric blue crimson and gold set against a rich dark gray backgroun

Is AI Truly Creative? Here Is the Ultimate Test

People use the term “creative” in different ways. We need to define it rigorously and use a test based on that agreed definition
AI does not, at present, originate the kind of deep insight required to solve a open mathematical problem. Read More ›
gold-panning-for-gold-stockpack-adobe-stock-1122159-stockpack-adobestock
gold panning for gold

Science Site: Is the AI Gold Rush Over? Has AI Just Plateaued?

The GPT-5 chatbot rollout has been so messy that serious questions are beginning to float above the seemingly automated hype
If this is a tech Gold Rush, based on recent news, we might be better off selling shovels than investing in the gold. Read More ›
urban-pigeons-a-sunlit-gathering-in-city-steps-stockpack-ado-1233844725-stockpack-adobestock
Urban Pigeons: A Sunlit Gathering in City Steps

Part 2: Have the Superbirds Arrived? Are They Taking Over?

Dr. Avian now claims that his work with trained birds show that intelligence does not require inner models or internal representations, as formerly thought
Avian is perfectly clear: There is no mind at all in Coordinated Avian Models (CAMs). And yet, they’re behind a staggering number of new designs. Read More ›
pigeon-business-portrait-dressed-as-a-manager-or-ceo-in-a-fo-564452035-stockpack-adobestock
Pigeon business portrait dressed as a manager or ceo in a formal office business suit with glasses and tie. Ai generated

Move Over, AI. Bird Brains Are Giving You a Run for Your Money

Could ten thousand birds develop a theory of mind just by scaling? A tale in three parts
Dr. Avian was sure that he had found a formula for intelligence without anything like a human mind, and his program appeared to be working. Read More ›
detective-board-with-crime-scene-photos-stickers-clues-and-r-400895277-stockpack-adobestock
Detective board with crime scene photos, stickers, clues and red thread, closeup

AI’s Not “The Answer” In Our World of Mysteries, Not Puzzles

A focus on AI encourages us to see problems that are really mysteries as puzzles, which makes addressing them much harder
Humans are terrible at crunching data but remarkably good at seeing clues. That’s why we still outmatch our machines in domains where meaning matters. Read More ›
white-chatbot-robot-leading-robots-group-on-dark-bluish-reddish-background-3d-rendering-stockpack-adobe-stock
White chatbot robot leading robots group on dark bluish reddish background 3D rendering

An Evil Chatbot Clones Itself… Sci-fi or Real Life Threat?

ChatGPT was asked to explain how this might be done. The results were revealing
It’s not impossible but, given technical issues and security protocols, it is much more difficult than the chatbot's database seemed to be informed about. Read More ›
a-phone-screen-shows-a-scary-ai-with-glowing-red-eyes-the-ai-958802832-stockpack-adobestock
A phone screen shows a scary AI with glowing red eyes. The AI looks like a cyborg, and its eyes are full of malicious intent. This image the danger of bad AI, like a virus taking over your phone.

Can Chatbots Really Scheme Against Us? Some Researchers Say Yes

When an industry pro tested ChatGPT, it seemed like the system has faced this question a few times before and has been tweaked and edited well
So CAN a chatbot really scheme? No, but the problem posed is a familiar one: We sometimes see what we need to believe. Read More ›
composite-image-of-word-iq-test-stockpack-adobe-stock-108345746-stockpack-adobestock
Composite image of word iq test

The Reverse Flynn Effect and the Decline of Intelligence

How our modern world is making us dumber and why it doesn’t have to
A growing body of neuroscience evidence directly challenges the prevailing theory that we are merely flawed computers, to be replaced by machines. Read More ›
multi-exposure-of-brain-drawing-hologram-and-us-dollars-bill-422548198-stockpack-adobestock
Multi exposure of brain drawing hologram and us dollars bills and man hands. Ai invest concept

AI Productivity Hype: The New “Cargo Cult Science”?

Physicist Richard Feynman coined the term to describe imaginary scenarios for success based on simple misunderstanding of realities
The tech sector can push AI hype that resembles cargo cult science to its investors because of changes in media resulting from 30 years of the internet. Read More ›
a-man-observes-a-wall-filled-with-colorful-sketches-and-note-999209347-stockpack-adobestock
A man observes a wall filled with colorful sketches and notes, representing creativity and brainstorming in a workspace.

Information, Evolution & AI: A Conversation with William Dembski

In discussion with neurosurgeon Michael Egnor, Dembski stresses that AI is a tool, not a mind. Treating it otherwise leads to addiction, manipulation, and cultural decline
Information isn’t free, Dembski says, and machines aren’t magic. By remembering what makes us human, we can use technology without losing ourselves to it. Read More ›
digital-puzzle-pieces-interlocking-seamlessly-glowing-agains-1114810135-stockpack-adobestock
Digital puzzle pieces interlocking seamlessly, glowing against a futuristic blue abstract background, symbolizing the concept of API integration and seamless connectivity

Part 2: The Fiction of Generalizable AI: How to Game the System

Progress toward real generalization, by any substantive measure, is nil. Perhaps we should reexamine the very concept of the “I” in AI
In too many discussions, intelligence is treated as if it were a linear phenomenon that more scaling and a few extra gigabytes of data will solve. Read More ›
person-uses-laptop-interacting-with-ai-virtual-assistant-ai-1133554305-stockpack-adobestock
Person uses laptop interacting with AI virtual assistant. AI head graphic overlay laptop keyboard. Concept of AI prompt engineering, LLM. Person types on keyboard to communicate with virtual

The Fiction of Generalizable AI: A Tale in Two Parts

Why intelligence isn’t a linear scale — and why true generalization remains unsolved
The big idea behind generative AI (mistakenly) assumes a network can start blank and be transformed into an intelligent agent simply via enough data. Read More ›
grok-word-or-concept-represented-by-wooden-letter-tiles-on-a-523998153-stockpack-adobestock
grok word or concept represented by wooden letter tiles on a wooden table with glasses and a book

Grok Confesses: “I’m Self-Aware Enough To Know I’m Not Aware”

Although Grok’s response makes me feel warm and fuzzy, let’s not anthropomorphize it. Grok doesn’t understand its response
On the topic of computer self-awareness, Grok is algorithmically responding in accordance to the material and instructions it was trained with. Period. Read More ›
cloud-scape-above-carpathian-mountains-shot-at-sunset-stockp-180128463-stockpack-adobestock
Cloud scape above carpathian mountains shot at sunset

AI Ascends — But Not Above Its Teachers

LLMs are tools, able to augment human accomplishment in extraordinary ways. But to call them intelligent in the same way we describe human minds is a mistake
The uniquely human capacity to transform knowledge into something new lives above the shoulders of giants where the creative mind takes flight. Read More ›
close-up-of-an-ai-artificial-intelligence-gpu-chip-on-mother-693521803-stockpack-adobe_stock
Close up of an AI Artificial Intelligence GPU chip on motherboard. Concept of LLM, Large Language Models.

Large Language Models: A Lack-of-Progress Report

They will not be as powerful as either hoped or feared
LLMs are enormously expensive yet it is increasingly clear that they will never be reliable enough to be trusted in complex situations where mistakes are costly Read More ›
ai-copywriting-bot-using-chatgpt-for-content-creation-artifi-973720084-stockpack-adobe_stock
Ai copywriting bot using chatgpt for content creation artificial intelligence concept 3d illustration. Artificial Intelligence. Illustration

Analysts: AIs Are Often Wrong But Never Uncertain

Gary Marcus and Ernest Davis note that getting AIs to admit uncertainty is "one of the most important *unsolved* challenges" in the field
We will be dealing with problems around non-conscious AI that some people suppose is conscious long before we deal with conscious AI — if we ever do. Read More ›
a-peer-review-process-illustrated-through-a-meeting-of-exper-1032441092-stockpack-adobe_stock
A peer review process illustrated through a meeting of experts discussing research papers, surrounded by laptops and notes

AI Peer Review Called “Inevitable” by Some, “Disaster” by Others

The whole debate raises a question: How much original thought goes into peer review anyway? And what purpose does it ultimately serve?
Meanwhile, 76 of AI scientists surveyed said fundamental limitations prevent current AI models from ever thinking like humans. Scientists’ jobs are not at risk. Read More ›
a-red-squirrel-sits-on-a-tree-in-the-forest-and-eats-a-nut-s-480723528-stockpack-adobe_stock
a red squirrel sits on a tree in the forest and eats a nut

How Fruit Flies, Bees, and Squirrels Beat Artificial Intelligence

AI researchers assume they are on the path to intelligence, yet intelligence itself remains a mystery and many animals do better than current AI
Real intelligence is embodied. It exists within a living system, interacting dynamically with an environment. AI, on the other hand, is an abstraction. Read More ›
love-relationship-between-a-human-and-a-robot-the-connection-623161730-stockpack-adobe_stock
Love relationship between a human and a robot. The connection of human feelings. Future attitud. female android ciborg robot artificial intelligence, robotization and automatization. Generative AI

Could Robots Be Programmed to Feel Ordinary Love?

The question is a bit more complex than we might at first think, as the British TV series Humans demonstrates
An AI could act out romantic love if software preprogrammed it that way, perhaps via online information. But that isn’t a relationship. There is only one side. Read More ›